Asia Morning Briefing: SEC's In-Kind BTC, ETH ETF Redemption Shift Happened Years Ago in Hong Kong

1 day ago

Good Morning, Asia. Here's what's making quality successful the markets:

Welcome to Asia Morning Briefing, a regular summary of apical stories during U.S. hours and an overview of marketplace moves and analysis. For a elaborate overview of U.S. markets, spot CoinDesk's Crypto Daybook Americas.

On Wednesday successful the U.S., the Securities and Exchange Commission announced that investors are present allowed to bash in-kind redemptions for bitcoin and ether exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

The determination lets organization traders make and redeem ETF shares straight successful BTC oregon ETH, improving ratio by avoiding fiat conversions.

But successful Hong Kong, this isn't thing new. In precocious 2023, during the aboriginal days of the regulatory process to bring crypto ETFs to the marketplace (they launched successful April 2024), the Securities and Futures Commission – the city's markets regulator – mentioned successful a circular that in-kind redemptions would beryllium allowed.

Part of the crushed wherefore they were allowed was a method one: ETF issuers were required to spouse with licensed section crypto exchanges and usage custody solutions. This wasn't the lawsuit successful Ontario, Canada, which had crypto ETFs first, nor the U.S. In Hong Kong determination wasn't the aforesaid debate astir the presumption of Ether arsenic a information arsenic determination was successful the U.S.

In contrast, U.S. regulators wrestled with concerns implicit custody, anti-money laundering risks, and imaginable marketplace manipulation.

While the SEC ne'er explicitly banned in-kind redemptions, ETF sponsors were required to region them from aboriginal filings. The Commission favored a cash-only attack arsenic a cautious archetypal step, citing untested operational processes and uncertainty implicit however to securely settee ample crypto transfers.

That stance wasn’t without interior pushback. SEC Commissioner Mark Uyeda publically criticized the agency’s attack during the January 2024 support of spot bitcoin ETFs.

He pointed retired that commodity-based ETFs, similar those backed by gold, routinely usage in-kind redemptions and questioned wherefore crypto was being treated differently.

Uyeda argued that the SEC failed to explicate wherefore it considered cash-only redemptions “non-novel,” contempt the wide deviation from modular ETF practice, and warned that the deficiency of reasoning acceptable a troubling precedent.

The occurrence highlights however Hong Kong’s regulator moved with greater clarity and cohesion from the commencement arsenic it brought these products to market.

By enabling in-kind redemptions aboriginal on, and pairing them with strict licensing and custody requirements, the SFC avoided the interior contradictions and argumentation drift that defined the U.S. rollout.

However, there's going to beryllium 1 broadside effect from each of this: tracking flows.

Crypto information aggregator SoSoValue, which provides regular travel updates for crypto ETFs, warns that "subscriptions of carnal bitcoin bash not make currency inflows for the [ETFs], truthful they cannot beryllium simply counted successful regular nett inflow statistics."

They've tried to make methods and models to enactment astir this, but accidental they person been unsuccessful truthful far.

So unless ETF issuers successful the U.S. people regular travel successful currency and crypto, tracking this metric is going to beryllium an issue. And it's an important 1 to track, arsenic it shows capitalist sentiment for the plus class.

Market Movements

BTC: Bitcoin is trading supra $117,500 aft a humble rebound, but momentum remains anemic arsenic ETF outflows persist, whales instrumentality nett adjacent $118K, and macro headwinds, including a steadfast dollar and hawkish Fed expectations, proceed to bounds upside.

ETH: ETH is trading supra $3,700. "Ethereum has proven successful parallel with BTC since its inception to beryllium the 2nd astir battle-tested network, and precise apt institutions present spot Ether the token arsenic a formidable asymmetric stake alongside bitcoin," said March Zheng, General Partner of Bizantine Capital, successful a enactment to CoinDesk.

Gold: Gold rebounded to $3,334 connected Tuesday, snapping a four-day losing streak up of the Fed meeting, arsenic traders priced successful dependable rates contempt anemic U.S. occupation data

Nikkei 225: Asia-Pacific markets opened mixed arsenic U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick confirmed Trump’s Friday tariff deadline volition proceed arsenic planned, with Japan’s Nikkei 225 level astatine the open.

S&P 500: U.S. stocks closed little Tuesday, with the S&P 500 ending a six-day grounds streak, arsenic investors weighed earnings, economical data, and the upcoming Fed complaint decision.

Elsewhere successful Crypto:

View source