Axie Infinity, Yield Guild Games & the play-to-earn economy

Around the Block from Coinbase Ventures sheds airy connected cardinal trends successful crypto. In this edition, Justin Mart, Connor Dempsey, and Hassan Ahmed research the maturation of NFT games and the play-to-earn economy. Plus, a look astatine NFT marketplace enactment and the Poly Network exploit.

We’re astatine an breathtaking clip successful crypto: 1 successful which cryptonetworks are blossoming into full-fledged virtual economies. Nowhere is this much connected show than with NFT gaming.

At the forefront of NFT gaming sits Axie Infinity and its play-to-earn model: a exemplary that pays radical successful crypto to play a amusive video game. With implicit one cardinal regular progressive users, Axie Infinity has exploded successful popularity successful emerging markets and is showing the imaginable to beryllium a trojan equine for on-boarding the adjacent procreation of crypto users.

On apical of that, Axie Infinity and play-to-earn gaming has spawned its ain thriving fiscal services sector.

The emergence of Axie Infinity

Over the past 30 days, Axie Infinity generated a caput turning $343M successful interest revenue. This is much than immoderate app oregon protocol successful crypto speech from the Ethereum blockchain, according to Token Terminal.

So where’s that gross coming from?

How Axie Infinity generates revenue

The Axie Infinity system consists of a governance token (AXS) and a 2nd token called Smooth Love Potion (SLP) that serves arsenic an in-game currency, on with NFTs that correspond some crippled characters and virtual existent estate.

The gameplay itself is often compared to Pokemon, wherever players conflict “Axies” (pictured below) against those of different players. Different Axies person antithetic strengths and weaknesses, and the strategy of the crippled comes down to playing to your Axies strengths amended than your opponent. Players get paid successful SLP for defeating opponents. Additionally, players tin vie regular quests to gain further SLP. Axies tin besides beryllium “bred” unneurotic to make caller Axies which tin successful crook beryllium sold to different players for profit.

Every clip an Axie is traded, a crippled of existent property is sold, oregon 2 Axies are bred, the protocol takes a interest priced successful a operation of AXS and SLP. Rather than spell to the developers, this gross is placed successful the Axie treasury, which has ballooned to astir $600 million.

An emerging markets phenomenon

While the protocol gross numbers unsocial picture the emergence of a caller breakout crypto application, what’s much breathtaking is where Axie Infinity is taking off: successful processing nations wherever players tin often gain much playing the crippled and selling SLP for their autochthonal currencies than they tin with a emblematic time job.

With an estimated 50% of regular progressive users (DAUs) coming from the Philippines, the crippled is besides picking up steam successful different emerging markets similar Indonesia, Brazil, Venezuela, India, and Vietnam.

Created by crippled developer Sky Mavis successful 2018, Axie started picking up integrated traction successful the Philippines successful aboriginal 2020 aft a fewer players realized they could marque morganatic incomes by playing. When Covid lockdowns deed and galore were enactment retired of work, much were encouraged to springiness it a try. A documentary connected the game’s maturation called PLAY-TO-EARN went viral successful May 2021 and DAUs went vertical soon after.

Business models of the metaverse

Unlike galore mobile games, Axie Infinity is not free to play. To get started, players request to get 3 Axie Infinity characters. In the earlier days of the game, the mean Axie was selling for nether $10. With the game’s accelerated maturation and the broader NFT rally, the mean Axie is present selling for astir $500 according to CryptoSlam.

Given Axie’s basal wrong the Philippines and different emerging markets, a $1,500 introduction tag is simply a non-starter for astir would-be players. To mitigate this obstruction to entry, an informal marketplace emerged successful which NFT owners began lending players the NFTs needed to play the crippled successful speech for a chopped of their winnings. This is done done QR codes that fto players usage Axie NFTs successful crippled without the lender having to cede ownership on-chain.

This informal marketplace has blossomed into a ceremonial play-to-earn fiscal services sector. The largest and astir salient subordinate is simply a task called Yield Guild Games.

Yield Guild Games (YGG)

Founder Gabby Dizon likes to accidental that Yield Guild Games is 1 portion Berkshire Hathaway and 1 portion Uber.

Just arsenic Berkshire Hathaway is simply a holding institution for a multitude of businesses, YGG is fundamentally a holding institution for play-to-earn gaming assets. Starting successful 2020, they’ve been buying up output producing NFTs, governance tokens, and ownership stakes successful promising gaming projects and protocols.

Similar to however Uber pairs radical who privation to gain wealth driving with radical who request rides, YGG pairs radical who privation to marque wealth gaming with the NFTs they request to gain successful play-to-earn games. In galore parts of the world, radical are opting to enactment with YGG implicit Uber simply due to the fact that it pays more.

YGG precocious released its July Asset & Treasury Report that offers an absorbing glimpse into the caller kinds of concern models NFTs and play-to-earn games are creating.

YGG by the numbers

Within YGG, determination are scholars and assemblage managers. Scholars person NFTs that they successful crook enactment to enactment earning crypto. Community managers enlistee and bid caller scholars. 70% of winnings spell to scholars, 20% to assemblage managers, and 10% to the Yield Guild Games treasury.

According to the report, 2,058 caller scholars joined YGG successful July bringing the full to 4,004. In the aforesaid month, YGG scholars generated 11.7M SLP by playing Axie Infinity, which equated to implicit $3.25M successful nonstop revenue. From April done July, scholars and assemblage managers person earned a cumulative of $8.93M.

From its chopped of each SLP earned by scholars, YGG earned $329,500 successful July and a full of $580,000 since April. YGG’s expenses presently outstrip revenue, arsenic they spent $1.62M successful July unsocial “breeding” caller Axie’s to conscionable student request (breeding tin cost anyplace from $200 to $1,200 per Axie).

The YGG Treasury

The YGG treasury consists of tokens and stablecoins held successful a wallet, NFTs, and task investments made successful assorted play-to-earn games. The task has been funded by a $1.325M effect round led by Delphi Digital and different $4.6M round from a16z. They besides raised $12.49M from the merchantability of the YGG governance token, portion holding 13.3% of its outstanding supply.

As of the extremity of July, the YGG wallet’s holdings stood astatine $415M, with the bulk stemming from the YGG token ($373M). The YGG token is portion of Yield Guild Game’s program to modulation into a community-governed DAO.

The terms of YGG has tripled successful August, meaning their treasury presently stands astatine implicit $1B.

Much of YGG’s superior has been enactment to enactment buying NFTs that tin gain output from play-to-earn games. By the extremity of July, the YGG treasury had amassed 19,460 NFTs valued astatine implicit $10M crossed 12 play-to-earn games. Axie Infinity NFTs comprised adjacent to 90% of that value.

YGG has besides made aboriginal signifier investments crossed 8 play-to-earn games via SAFT (Simple Agreement for Future Tokens), and locked successful ~$1M for output farming successful blue-chip DeFi projects.

Play-to-earn successful the existent world

A cardinal constituent of the YGG exemplary is that players are lent NFTs with zero downside hazard and without having to enactment down immoderate upfront capital. In return, they surrender 30% of their winnings but clasp the bulk — a captious hook to onboarding a caller people of crypto users that person historically been priced out.

In fact, immoderate players successful the Philippines are earning 5–10x what they were making from their erstwhile jobs. New homes person been purchased, charitable acts person been made, and adjacent shops are accepting SLP arsenic payment.

Beyond the wealthiness Axie Infinity has created, the game’s popularity has served arsenic a means for getting a ample caller people of users comfy utilizing crypto applications. As these 1 cardinal users interface with cryptocurrencies, NFTs, integer wallets, and DEXs, it’s not hard to spot this caller cohort arsenic earthy users of different DeFi and Web3 applications.

Play-to-earn sustainability

If Axie Infinity is its ain integer nation, crippled developer Sky Mavis serves arsenic its Federal Reserve. Where the Fed has assorted tools it uses to power the economy, Sky Mavis tin set the SLP issuance complaint and breeding fees with the purpose of keeping the Axie system healthy. Just similar a existent economy, integer economies person to see the effects of inflation.

ETH has been flowing into the Axie system owed to precocious request for Axie NFTs. Increased request for Axie NFTs has led to rising Axie NFT prices. Higher NFT prices person made breeding much profitable. Breeding requires fees paid successful SLP & AXS, starring to a emergence successful token prices. With rising SLP prices, playing becomes much profitable, encouraging others to join. A almighty affirmative feedback loop nary uncertainty — but what if marketplace conditions change?

Winning Axie Infinity battles and quests yields SLP, inflating the SLP supply. And since breeding is priced successful SLP, further proviso of SLP equates to cheaper breeding fees to make caller Axie NFTs, inflating Axie NFT supply. These dynamics could person an interaction connected NFT marketplace prices, which successful crook whitethorn person a nonstop effect connected the economics for players — a imaginable antagonistic feedback loop.

Ultimately, Sky Mavis has to support the SLP proviso in-check portion improving wide gameplay to support its subordinate system and ETH deposits growing. They indispensable besides offset the fig of players seeking to extract a nett with players who are axenic consumers — i.e. playing for the amusive of it.

Playing the Long Game

While Sky Mavis works to support the Axie system strong, Yield Guild Games is banking connected the continued maturation of play-to-earn gaming arsenic a whole. By replicating its exemplary for Axie Infinity crossed caller games, it seeks to physique a play-to-earn empire. Over the agelong run, laminitis Gabby Dizon sees YGG arsenic the “recruitment bureau of the metaverse” that yet competes with the Ubers of the satellite for labor. A aboriginal consecutive retired of Ready Player One successful which millions of radical gain a surviving successful the integer satellite successful bid to screen expenses successful the carnal one.

Final word

With the exploding gross of Axie Infinity, the emergence of DAOs similar Yield Guild Games, and the multitude of play-to-earn games connected the horizon, it’s wide that this inclination has legs. With DeFi, NFTs, and present crypto gaming, we’re rapidly evolving past the archetypal crypto slayer app of speculative trading and into a beingness of expressive caller apps and models. We’re successful fascinating times arsenic crypto’s inferior signifier marches guardant with a afloat caput of steam.

OpenSea Hits $3B monthly volume

In the period of August, NFT speech OpenSea deed $3B successful monthly measurement arsenic implicit 1.5 cardinal NFTs changed hands. Its August measurement unsocial exceeds that of each different period successful its history, combined.

OpenSea’s August measurement is connected par with $3B successful gross income Etsy enactment up successful each of Q2: different motion of conscionable however large the NFT marketplace has grown comparative to different online marketplaces successful a precise abbreviated timespan.

Data from The Block shows however ascendant OpenSea’s dominance implicit the NFT scenery truly is.

Notably absent from this speech scenery are immoderate benignant of decentralized venues for trading NFTs. This follows past marketplace cycles successful which centralized exchanges recovered merchandise marketplace acceptable first, earlier yet paving the mode for decentralized alternatives (think Uniswap during the DeFi summer).

The DEX marketplace for NFTs is inactive nascent but 1 we’re watching is the precocious launched Punks.house which is simply a permissionless venue for trading CryptoPunks made by Zora. We’re besides seeing NFT markets statesman to decentralize themselves, with NFT creation marketplace Super Rare making the archetypal determination with the instauration of its RARE governance token. Many fishy OpenSea volition yet instrumentality this way arsenic well.

Lastly, portion OpenSea is simply a centralized for nett entity, its codification is unfastened source. It wouldn’t astonishment america to spot a low-fee rival forked from OpenSea look successful the coming months.

In the largest DeFi hack to date, an attacker drained implicit $611M from the Ethereum, Binance Smart Chain, and Polygon blockchains. Then successful a astonishment move, helium returned astir each of it.

The hack was done by exploiting vulnerabilities connected the Poly Network, a cross-chain interoperability protocol that connects antithetic blockchains. These types of networks are usually among the astir complex, owing to challenges successful getting 2 antithetic blockchains to speech to each different successful a secure, harmless manner (it’s hard capable getting 1 blockchain to beryllium secure!). And complexity is the force of information due to the fact that added complexity increases the aboveground country for attackers to find exploits.

In this case, the hacker tricked Poly Network’s astute contracts into reasoning that the hacker’s code had support to unlock the $611M+ crossed chains (detailed method investigation here, elemental explainer here). But successful an unusual crook of events, the hacker ended up returning astir each of it to the Poly Network squad (sans $33M USDT frozen by Tether).

There remains speculation astir the hacker’s motives to instrumentality the funds. Security steadfast SlowMist stated that they were capable to place the hacker’s IP and email addresses, truthful immoderate deliberation the funds were returned due to the fact that the hacker knew they wouldn’t beryllium capable to launder that overmuch wealth undetected. The hacker, connected the different hand, conducted an AMA and stated that they did it, “for fun.” And successful a abstracted twist, the Poly Network squad offered the hacker a occupation arsenic their Chief Security Officer successful summation to sending a $500,000 bounty for returning immoderate of the funds.

What’s going connected here? We can’t cognize for sure, but it is uncommon for a hacker to instrumentality funds, particularly successful specified a nationalist fashion. Occam’s razor suggests that the repercussions progressive with getting caught (if their info was genuinely identified) were excessively large to bear.

While it’s disconcerting to spot much hacks happening, we should enactment that this is simply an evolutionary fitness-function successful action. Each hack teaches america however to improve, and we learn, adapt, and improve. While bleeding borderline crypto protocols pioneering caller usage cases volition inevitably transportation much risk, the abstraction hardens implicit time.

And Poly Network is not alone. Note the different week erstwhile Paradigm’s samczsun discovered and reported a vulnerability successful SushiSwap’s MISO level that would person near $350M ETH astatine risk. Most recently, Cream Finance was exploited successful a flashloan attack for $25M.

But for crypto to truly succeed, we request information guarantees. Insurance markets are critical.

This website does not disclose worldly nonpublic accusation pertaining to Coinbase oregon Coinbase Venture’s portfolio companies.

Disclaimer: This worldly is the spot of Coinbase, Inc., its genitor and affiliates (“Coinbase”). The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the writer and bash not needfully bespeak the views of Coinbase oregon its employees and summarizes accusation and articles with respect to cryptocurrencies oregon related topics that the writer believes whitethorn beryllium of interest. This worldly is for informational purposes only, and is not (i) an offer, oregon solicitation of an offer, to put in, oregon to bargain oregon sell, immoderate interests oregon shares, oregon to enactment successful immoderate concern oregon trading strategy, (ii) intended to supply accounting, legal, oregon taxation advice, oregon concern recommendations oregon (iii) an authoritative connection of Coinbase. No practice oregon warranty is made, expressed oregon implied, with respect to the accuracy oregon completeness of the accusation oregon to the aboriginal show of immoderate integer asset, fiscal instrumentality oregon different marketplace oregon economical measure. The accusation is believed to beryllium existent arsenic of the day indicated connected the materials. Recipients should consult their advisors earlier making immoderate concern decision. Coinbase whitethorn person fiscal interests in, oregon relationships with, immoderate of the entities and/or publications discussed oregon different referenced successful the materials. Certain links that whitethorn beryllium provided successful the materials are provided for convenience and bash not connote Coinbase’s endorsement, oregon support of immoderate third-party websites oregon their content. Coinbase, Inc. is not registered oregon licensed successful immoderate capableness with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission oregon the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission.