Bitcoin Mining Around The World: Norway’s Outsized Presence Relative To Its Size

2 years ago

bitcoin mining astir the satellite Norway

The beneath nonfiction is portion of a larger bid connected Bitcoin mining astir the satellite compiled by the squad astatine Arcane Research.

This is the 2nd nonfiction successful a bid describing the bitcoin mining manufacture successful assorted countries astir the world. The archetypal nonfiction covered Georgia, and I present bash a akin investigation connected Norway. Coming from Norway, I person first-hand cognition of the country’s bitcoin mining industry. Also, I enactment for Arcane, which has a mining cognition successful Norway.

I volition explicate wherefore the bitcoin mining manufacture is flourishing successful Norway, focusing connected the powerfulness marketplace and regulatory situation portion besides providing an overview of each the mining operations successful the country.

A Large Mining Industry Given The Country’s Small Size

We should archetypal find retired however large Norway’s bitcoin mining manufacture is. I volition supply a mates of existing estimates earlier coming up with my ain numbers.

Cambridge’s Bitcoin Mining Map, which estimates the hashrate stock of each country, gives Norway 0.58% of Bitcoin’s hashrate. Multiplying this stock with their 15.6 GW estimation for the Bitcoin mining network's full powerfulness request gives Norwegian miners a powerfulness gully of 90 megawatt (MW), assuming their hardware has the aforesaid powerfulness ratio arsenic the web average.

CoinShares besides estimated the size of Norway’s bitcoin mining manufacture and recovered it having 66 MW of installed power. While Cambridge’s top-down methodology utilized information from 4 mining pools to estimation the geographic organisation of miners, CoinShares applied a bottom-up process to place each the mining facilities successful each country.

Similar to CoinShares, I did my champion to representation retired each the mining facilities successful Norway and identified 120 MW of existent bitcoin mining operations successful Norway, which you tin find connected the representation below. This powerfulness draw, multiplied by Сambridge’s estimation for the Bitcoin mining network’s full powerfulness demand, means Norwegian bitcoin miners nutrient 0.77% of Bitcoin’s hashrate.

Who Mines Bitcoin In Norway?

Generating astir 1% of Bitcoin’s hashrate, Norwegian miners are not the biggest but inactive important contributors successful securing the network. Who are they?

The manufacture consists of immoderate section and respective ample planetary companies. Local players see Kryptovault and Arcane Green Data, portion Northern Data, Bitdeer, Bitzero and COWA are among the larger planetary companies.

You tin work much astir each installation successful the appendix astatine the bottommost of the article.

A Green Oasis Of Renewable Energy

Now we volition commencement exploring what attracted each these miners to Norway.

Mining is an energy-intensive manufacture nether dense nationalist unit regarding its c footprint. Therefore, a apical precedence for miners is powering their operations with renewable energy.

With its mountainous terrain and bedewed climate, Norway is made for hydropower. The buildout of hydroelectric powerfulness stations started astatine the extremity of the 19th century. Since then, hydro has been Norway’s superior root of electricity, giving the state an abundance of cheap, reliable and greenish power.

electricity procreation by root successful norway

In a emblematic year, 88% of energy generated successful Norway comes from hydro and 10% from wind. Except for a 2% stock of earthy state powering the Norwegian offshore lipid shelf, Norway is powered by 100% renewable energy, making the state charismatic to miners who privation to mitigate their c footprint.

Things look large present and now, but however volition energy procreation successful Norway make successful the coming years?

Norway has monolithic imaginable for caller hydropower development, but getting improvement permissions has gotten harder. NVE (Norwegian Water and Energy Authority) estimates that until 2040, lone 11 TWh of caller hydroelectric procreation volition beryllium installed, corresponding to a meager 8% summation from today’s capacity.

Although the onshore upwind capableness has grown fast, NVE estimates it volition lone spot a 3 TWh maturation until 2040. On the different hand, the offshore upwind capableness volition turn fast, from 0 to 7 TWh successful the aforesaid period. And judge it oregon not, star could besides summation from 0 to 7 TWh.

future estimation of powerfulness procreation by source

As you tin see, not overmuch volition alteration connected the powerfulness procreation broadside successful Norway until 2040, but for a small higher stock of upwind and solar.

The astir important takeaway for bitcoin miners regarding Norway’s energy premix is that it’s afloat renewable, and volition enactment that way.

The Further North, The Cheaper Electricity

With zero marginal outgo of hydroelectric power, Norway has enjoyed immoderate of Europe’s cheapest electricity. Although the state is divided into 5 energy price zones, prices person historically been akin successful each zones. That changed successful 2021.

historical powerfulness prices successful norway

In the past 5 years, powerfulness prices usually stayed betwixt $0.03 and $0.05 per kilowatt-hour (kWh) successful each the terms zones, lone interrupted successful 2020 erstwhile they fell beneath $0.01 per kWh, caused by higher-than-average precipitation that filled up the hydropower reservoirs.

After an unusually inexpensive 2020, Southern Norway’s energy consumers were shocked successful 2021 arsenic they saw a seven-fold summation successful their prices, portion consumers successful the Northern and Middle regions didn’t spot akin increases.

There are respective explanations for the abrupt determination terms differences, but the astir important origin is that the confederate portion of Norway has go heavy connected with the remainder of Europe’s powerfulness markets arsenic caller underwater powerfulness lines to the continent were opened astatine the extremity of 2020 and the opening of 2021.

With Southern Norway truthful connected to the European markets, the prices connected the continent straight power our home powerfulness prices. 2021 was a twelvemonth with record-high vigor prices globally, with gas, ember and CO2 prices shooting done the roof, making energy costly successful Europe, further dragging up prices successful Southern Norway.

Due to transmission constraints betwixt Middle Norway and Southern Norway, lone the confederate portion of the state is afloat connected with the European market. The mediate and bluish regions are inactive enjoying debased prices owed to the limited transmission capacity.

Power Will Stay Expensive In The South And Cheap In The North

With Norway connected to the volatile European market, it’s uncertain however energy prices volition make successful the future. National grid relation Statnett expects the powerfulness prices to gradually alteration owed to European state and ember prices “normalizing.”

estimates for aboriginal powerfulness prices successful norway

Statnett’s investigation is from earlier Russia invaded Ukraine. The struggle has already led to soaring substance prices, putting upward unit connected European powerfulness prices. Therefore, I don’t stock Statnett’s optimism that substance prices volition “normalize,” and I expect powerfulness prices to enactment astatine elevated levels successful Southern Norway.

Although prices volition enactment precocious successful the South, I don’t expect akin terms increases successful the North soon. With record-high prices successful Southern Norway, they would emotion to pat into Northern Norway’s energy but can’t, owed to constricted transmission capacity. Statnett plans to physique new transmission lines to alleviate these constraints until 2030, and I expect the terms spread to persist astatine slightest until then.

Norwegian Miners Want To Contribute To The Energy Sector

Norwegian miners are exploring however to summation their information successful the vigor sector, either by providing balancing services successful the powerfulness marketplace oregon by reusing the excess vigor from their operations.

The request for energy-intensive industries similar bitcoin miners to assistance equilibrium the energy strategy is expanding arsenic upwind and solar’s stock of the procreation capableness grows. The energy proviso and request indispensable ever beryllium successful balance, and historically we person been capable to supply this equilibrium by simply adjusting production. Because upwind and star are upwind dependent, we can’t easy set their accumulation to travel the demand.

Norway’s grid relation Statnett understands that the request for grid balancing volition increase, and truthful opened a balancing market this twelvemonth wherever demand-side resources similar bitcoin miners tin participate. Bitcoin mining is highly suitable for grid balancing since the process is some energy-intensive and tin beryllium interrupted astatine astir nary cost. You tin larn much astir that successful this article, explaining however miners are helping stabilize Texas’ energy system.

In addition, galore Norwegian bitcoin miners are experimenting with reusing excess vigor from their operations. These waste-minimization initiatives tin payment Norway, some from an economical and ecological position since heating makes up a important share of a acold country’s vigor consumption. At the aforesaid time, vigor is bitcoin miners’ main discarded component.

Kryptovault has been reusing the vigor from their Hønefoss cognition to adust lumber for much than 2 years. The institution collects the vigor from its mining cognition successful pipes and donates it to a local lumber company that employs six radical astatine the site, reducing discarded and creating section jobs.

Lumber waiting to beryllium dried extracurricular of Kryptovault’s Hønefoss facility.

Kryptovault’s lumber-drying task is conscionable 1 of galore imaginable applications of reusing vigor from bitcoin mining. Miners are looking astatine possibilities for connecting to territory heating systems, heating fish farms, greenhouses, pools, spas, etc. The imaginable is enormous, and I judge that we volition spot this process flourish successful Norway successful the coming years.

A Politically Stable Country, But Bitcoin Mining Is Controversial

In summation to looking for inexpensive and greenish electricity, miners question jurisdictions with favorable regulatory environments and governmental stability.

Norway is 1 of the world’s astir politically unchangeable countries, with acceptable regulatory conditions for astir businesses, giving it ninth spot successful the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business Index.

Still, the bitcoin mining manufacture is not the astir fashionable successful the state and has faced immoderate governmental opposition. To recognize the governmental risk, you indispensable cognize astir the power-tax saga from 2019.

While astir powerfulness consumers successful Norway wage a power tax of NOK 0.1541 ($0.017) per kWh, the energy-intensive concern assemblage pays lone NOK 0.0055 ($0.0006) per kWh. In 2016, the Norwegian authorities made information centers eligible for this reduced power-tax complaint to pull much of them to Norway.

The authorities hoped for Google oregon Facebook but alternatively got bitcoin miners. Displeased by however their regulations backfired, they decided to revoke the reduced taxation complaint specifically for crypto miners successful 2019. As a result, miners’ energy prices abruptly accrued by $0.016 per kWh, a important magnitude successful an manufacture with a median powerfulness terms of $0.04.

Many Norwegian information centers are combined facilities, partially hosting bitcoin miners. Therefore, this taxation hike affected a important stock of the information halfway industry. In addition, information centers that weren’t straight affected started to question the antecedently indisputable governmental stableness of operating successful Norway, and the country’s fantabulous planetary estimation successful the manufacture began to crack.

The full assemblage rapidly joined forces and started warring against the taxation hike, backed by the Confederation of Norwegian Enterprises (NHO) and the Norwegian IT association, IKT Norge.

In 2020, the Norwegian authorities gave successful to the unit and decided not to revoke the reduced powerfulness taxation aft all. They whitethorn person realized that specified a granular selectivity successful their decision-making for who is eligible for a reduced powerfulness taxation is astir apt successful struggle with respective Norwegian and planetary laws.

Still, the harm was already done. Bitmain, Hive Blockchain and respective different companies decided to permission Norway due to the fact that of the accrued regulatory uncertainty.

Bitcoin miners are considered eligible for the reduced powerfulness tax, but we whitethorn not person seen the extremity of the saga yet. Some Norwegian politicians inactive haven’t fixed up connected expanding miners’ powerfulness tax, portion immoderate adjacent privation to ban bitcoin mining.

Recently we person besides seen attempts connected regulatory restrictions from the EU, of which Norway is not a member. However, the EU inactive has a sizeable power connected Norwegian authorities since Norway is, done assorted agreements, obliged to comply with a ample portion of the EU’s regulations.

In November 2021, Swedish regulators projected a draught for an EU-wide Bitcoin prohibition from 2025. Norwegian section authorities and determination improvement curate Bjørn Arild Gram announced that helium would effort to transcript the prohibition successful Norway if it passed the ballot successful the European Parliament. In the end, the prohibition effort was unsuccessful.

Luckily, Norway doesn’t person a agelong past of populistic bans connected definite activities based connected subjective opinions. In addition, definite planetary agreements besides support industries from authorities overreach. Therefore, adjacent though fractions successful the nationalist authorities whitethorn not similar it, it’s precise improbable that mining volition go regulatorily infeasible successful Norway.

Conclusion

Thanks to its inexpensive and cleanable power, acold clime and governmental stability, Norway has attracted an outsized bitcoin mining assemblage considering the nation’s tiny population.

From 2021, important powerfulness terms differences emerged betwixt the confederate and bluish parts of the country. These terms gaps volition persist and truthful miners should ideally find their operations successful the overmuch cheaper North.

Even though Norway is considered 1 of the astir politically unchangeable countries globally, the bitcoin mining manufacture remains arguable and faces immoderate governmental opposition. Examples are the Norwegian government’s unsuccessful effort to rise powerfulness taxes specifically for miners and Swedish regulators’ failed EU-wide Bitcoin ban.

Still, we should support successful caput that the bitcoin mining manufacture is not lone arguable successful Norway but besides successful astir different countries. Therefore, comparative to astir different alternate countries for bitcoin mining extracurricular North America, I don’t see Norway 1 of the astir politically hostile to the industry.

Recently, North America has soaked up a ample stock of the mining capacity, and I presume immoderate of these miners look astatine Norway arsenic a imaginable determination to diversify their operations geographically.

Also, arsenic miners progressively look nationalist unit successful utilizing renewable energy, tapping into the Norwegian greenish hydropower becomes adjacent much attractive.

Because of these reasons, I expect the bitcoin mining manufacture successful Norway to support growing, particularly successful the bluish portion of the country.

If you would similar to sermon bitcoin mining with maine oregon person questions astir mining successful Norway, delight scope retired to maine @jmellerud connected Twitter.

Appendix: Overview Of Norwegian Miners

Here are each the mining facilities I identified successful Norway.

Kryptovault In Hønefoss

Kryptovault successful Hønefoss is the biggest installation successful Norway, with 45 MW of bitcoin mining capacity. They are presently operating astir 18 MW since they are successful the process of replacing their older ASICs with newer and much energy-efficient models.

In 2018, Kryptovault rebuilt Norske Skog’s insubstantial mill successful Hønefoss, which had been abandoned since 2012. On this site, Kryptovault reuses discarded vigor from their mining operations for drying lumber.

Kryptovault In Dale

In summation to their Hønefoss facility, Kryptovault operates a 25 MW installation successful Dale. Currently, they utilize astir 8 MW of the facility’s capacity.

The Dale information halfway is located successful a gathering that erstwhile was Norway’s largest textile factory. This revitalization of abandoned concern buildings helps bring caller beingness to aged buildings and saves Kryptovault concern costs and improvement time.

COWA And Lian Group In Mo

Cowa and Lian Group’s installation successful Mo, successful the North, is the country’s 2nd largest with a capableness of 40 MW, of which 36 MW is presently used. Bitfury built this installation successful 2018 and self-mined present until 2022.

Bitdeer In Molde

Cloud mining level Bitdeer hosts 38 MW successful the Troll Housing information halfway extracurricular Molde. Troll Housing’s installation utilizes a erstwhile mine, wherever the clime conditions are cleanable for bitcoin mining year-round.

Although readying a nationalist listing, Bitdeer is reluctant to stock accusation connected its operations, but according to an investor prospectus from January 2022, they person 38 MW of mining successful Molde. The lone information halfway I could find successful the Molde country with capable capableness to big 38 MW is Troll Housing. Therefore, I’m reasonably definite that Troll Housing is hosting Bitdeer.

Bitdeer In Tydal

Bitdeer is expanding its Norway operations with a 50 MW information halfway nether improvement successful Tydal. Troll Housing, which besides hosts Bitdeer’s Molde operation, is constructing the Tydal information center.

Bitdeer’s astir caller investor prospectus confirms this information center.

Bitzero In Tunnsjødal

Canadian miner Bitzero is processing a installation successful Tunnsjødal. With 100 MW nether development, the installation tin perchance go the biggest successful Norway erstwhile finished successful 2023. Having completed the archetypal improvement step, Bitzero presently mines with 7 MW.

The installation is located adjacent to Tunnsjødal Power Station, the biggest powerfulness works successful the cardinal portion of Norway, with an installed capableness of 176 MW.

Arcane Green Data In Fyresdal

Arcane Green Data has since 2021 hosted 2.5 MW successful Oslofjord Datacenter successful Fyresdal, presently operating adjacent to afloat capacity.

Oslofjord Datacenter is simply a combined installation that lone uses portion of its capableness for bitcoin mining. In summation to hosting Arcane Green Data, they besides big 2.5 MW for different bitcoin miner, giving their information halfway a full bitcoin mining capableness of 5 MW.

Bluebite In Bodø

The German institution Bluebite has since 2019 operated a 1 MW information halfway successful the Arctic metropolis of Bodø wrong a gathering antecedently utilized for the accumulation of marine equipment. The institution considers the Bodø information halfway arsenic a aviator task portion looking for enlargement opportunities successful bluish Norway.

Bluebite In Sulitjelma

Bluebite is processing a information halfway successful Sulitjelma, a erstwhile mining municipality 1 hr from Bodø. In summation to doing unreality computing, they are presently mining with 4 MW but are looking to expand.

Bluebite is revitalizing 1 of the town’s galore abandoned concern buildings, bringing caller concern enactment successful the signifier of bitcoin mining to the erstwhile copper mining powerhouse of Sulitjelma.

Making a section interaction is simply a apical precedence for Bluebite, truthful they program to reuse excess vigor from their information halfway for a greenhouse oregon spa to make adjacent much section jobs.

New Mining Company In Alvdal

New Mining Company is simply a Russian radical mining bitcoin since 2018 successful Alvdal. Their 3 MW cognition has been highly controversial, with neighbors complaining astir the sound and immoderate adjacent suspecting the institution of utilizing their mining activities arsenic a screen for a Russian spy operation.

mining institution installation successful alvdal

After a bid of disagreements, the section authorities terminated their land-lease statement with New Mining Company, giving them 1 twelvemonth to permission the property.

Northern Data In Måløy

Although this nonfiction focuses connected bitcoin miners, I decided to see 1 large ether miner. German institution Northern Data mines ether with a capableness of 25 MW heavy wrong a upland successful the Lefdal Mine information halfway successful Måløy successful the occidental portion of Norway.

Lefdal Mine is 1 of respective abandoned mines successful Norway which person been turned into information centers. As 1 of Europe’s largest information centers, they besides person respective non-mining customers.

Northern Data In Notodden

After having mined crypto heavy wrong the upland successful Lefdal Mine since 2018, Northern Data expanded their Norway operations with a 40 MW information halfway successful Notodden successful 2021.

The information halfway is located successful the concern parkland Hydroparken, and similar astir miners successful Norway, Northern Data are exploring however to reuse the excess heat.

Northern Data In Vassbygdi

In 2021 Northern Data bought an aged concern gathering successful Vassbygdi, heavy wrong Sognefjorden, Norway’s longest fjord.

It’s unclear whether they excavation bitcoin, ether oregon usage the information halfway for different high-performance computing purposes. Still, conscionable similar successful their Notodden information center, a job ad reveals that they are looking for engineers to enactment connected GPUs, truthful they apt excavation ether here.

Hydrokraft In Glomfjord

Hydrokraft is constructing a 30 MW information halfway successful Glomfjord successful bluish Norway, readying to decorativeness it aboriginal successful 2022. The information halfway is located successful Glomfjord Industripark, an concern hub consisting of 19 companies. Hydrokraft has ambitions of reusing vigor from the information halfway for different concern applications.

This is simply a impermanent station by Jaran Mellerud. Opinions expressed are wholly their ain and bash not needfully bespeak those of BTC Inc oregon Bitcoin Magazine.

View source