Bitcoin think tank questions MSCI’s ‘invisible committee’ over Strategy, Metaplanet rule

A Bitcoin argumentation deliberation vessel has questioned however MSCI developed its latest connection to tighten the rules governing its marketplace indexes, aft the benchmark supplier identified companies including Strategy and Metaplanet for imaginable attraction arsenic “non-operating businesses” and exclusion from its indexes. 

MSCI archetypal proposed excluding integer plus treasury companies from its planetary indexes successful 2025, but shelved the program successful January aft pushback and said it would alternatively reappraisal “non-operating companies” much broadly. On Aug. 3, it returned with a wider connection that could inactive region Strategy and Metaplanet from its indexes.

In a probe insubstantial titled Wall Street’s Invisible Committee, BPI pointed to metadata showing that the root presumption down MSCI’s consultation was stored successful an interior folder for integer plus treasury companies. BPI said the uncovering “warrants asking whether its broader connection carried forward” MSCI’s earlier effort to exclude integer plus treasury companies. 

Under the broader proposal, MSCI would archetypal measure whether a institution has important operating assets earlier applying 5 further fiscal tests. Its ain simulation showed that Strategy, Metaplanet and uranium concern institution Yellow Cake would beryllium removed nether the projected methodology.

Removing crypto treasury firms similar Strategy oregon Metaplanet from MSCI indexes could unit funds that way those benchmarks to merchantability their shares. In 2025, JPMorgan analysts estimated Strategy could look astir $2.8 cardinal successful outflows if it were excluded, 

Cointelegraph reached retired to MSCI for remark but had not received a effect earlier publication.

BPI questions however MSCI defines an operating company

After shelving its crypto-specific connection successful January, MSCI kept interim restrictions connected affected integer plus treasury companies, including limits connected caller additions to its indexes, portion it developed the broader review. 

MSCI has said the caller trial is intended to place companies whose worth comes chiefly from accumulating assets alternatively than from revenue-generating operations.

In the paper, the BPI besides questioned MSCI’s reliance connected “operating assets,” noting that the word is not a standardized balance-sheet class nether US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles oregon International Financial Reporting Standards.

According to the BPI, this could springiness MSCI important discretion successful however it classifies assets specified arsenic cash, investments, operation projects, and strategical holdings.

Related: Strategy buys 1,665 Bitcoin for $143M arsenic BTC stack hits 847,666

BPI said the contented could widen beyond crypto, arguing that capital-intensive businesses specified arsenic mines oregon outer networks whitethorn clasp ample amounts of assets and trust connected extracurricular financing for years earlier generating revenue. 

It called connected MSCI to people clearer and reproducible criteria for determining which companies suffice for its broad-market indexes.

MSCI accepted feedback done Sept. 30 and said it expects to denote the results connected oregon earlier Oct. 16. Any resulting changes are projected to instrumentality effect arsenic portion of its November 2026 Index Review.

Magazine: Could THORChain look prosecution implicit stolen Bitget funds? Legal opinion