DAOs: Social networks that can rewire the world

2 years ago

Exploring the caller satellite of decentralized autonomous organizations

Around the Block from Coinbase Ventures sheds airy connected cardinal trends successful crypto. Written by Justin Mart & Connor Dempsey.

What the net did for communication, DAOs tin bash for capital.

The net and societal networks person made it easier for similar minded individuals to pass than ever before, careless of geographic location. The advent of digitally autochthonal wealth and concern person present enabled a caller benignant of societal web that allows for similar minded individuals to not conscionable communicate, but besides coordinate astir capital. As with their predecessors, these caller networks are unconstrained by geographic borders, susceptible of forming astatine monolithic standard oregon crossed a tiny fig of prime participants.

The astir optimistic thinkers judge that decentralized autonomous organizations tin reinvent however humans signifier and yet eclipse the size and scope of the world’s largest corporations and adjacent nation-states.

In this variation of Around The Block, we research the existent DAO scenery and large questions surrounding their future.

What is a DAO?

Simply put, DAOs are bundle enabled organizations. They let radical to excavation resources toward a communal extremity and stock successful worth instauration erstwhile those goals are achieved.

Just arsenic the LLC (limited liability corporation) was the preferred organizing primitive of the concern revolution, DAOs tin beryllium the aforesaid for Web3. Where corporations are rooted successful the bequest fiscal strategy and organized done ineligible contracts, DAOs tally connected apical of unfastened blockchain networks similar Ethereum, organized by tokens with their rules encoded successful astute contracts.

DAOs aren’t tied to a carnal location, which allows them to mobilize rapidly and pull endowment from each implicit the world — a conception that was connected afloat show erstwhile the ConstitutionDAO precocious raised implicit $40M from 17,000 contributors successful little than a week successful a failed bid to bargain 1 of the archetypal copies of the US constitution.

But DAOs tin bash truthful overmuch much than mobilize net friends to collectively bid connected historical documents — they tin alteration however we signifier immoderate mode of economical activity.

What bash DAOs do?

There are already implicit 180 DAOs (tracked by deepdao.io) with $10B+ successful assets nether absorption and astir 2 cardinal members. These scope from DAOs that assistance negociate immoderate of the largest protocols successful crypto, to smaller DAOs organized astir investment, societal communities, media, and philanthropic pursuits.

Protocol DAOs

Ethereum led to an detonation of caller crypto assets. From there, developers created protocols that fto radical commercialized and lend these caller assets (like Uniswap, Compound, and Aave). However these protocols were intended to beryllium decentralized, which created a request to fig retired however to govern their maturation and evolution.

Rather than enactment each cardinal determination successful the hands of a tiny squad of developers, protocol DAOs emerged arsenic a mode to springiness a protocol’s users a corporate accidental successful its aboriginal direction. Typically, users are issued governance tokens, often straight based connected past usage and contributions, that convey voting rights. Any idiosyncratic tin suggest ways to amended the project, and token holders tin ballot connected whether oregon not the developers should determination guardant with the proposal. More tokens = much voting power.

For example, Uniswap token holders are presently voting connected which layer 2 networks the decentralized speech protocol should beryllium deployed on. Token holders besides suggest and ballot connected thing from selling initiatives to however Uniswap’s $2B+ treasury should be managed.

Governance tokens align the assemblage astir the aboriginal occurrence of the protocol, arsenic they should admit successful worth arsenic the protocol grows — or autumn should it fail.

As of December 7th, the largest protocol DAOs by AUM are Uniswap, Lido, Radicle*, Compound,* Olympus, and Aave.

Investment / Collector DAOs

The 2nd largest class is concern and collector DAOs. These fto radical excavation superior with the purpose of investing successful circumstantial assets. They scope from task investments successful things similar DeFi protocols oregon NFTs, to progressively ambitious efforts similar buying rare historical documents oregon adjacent professional sports franchises.

Similar to different forms of crypto crowdfunding, these DAOs connection a accelerated and elemental means of superior formation erstwhile compared to costly and analyzable ineligible setups associated with a emblematic task superior fund. These funds are besides much transparent than accepted task funds, since members tin audit each transactions on chain.

PleasrDAO, MetaCartel Ventures, Flamingo, Komerabi, are each large examples of DAOs pooling resources, collectively making concern decisions, and sharing successful the upside erstwhile those investments appreciate. In a akin vein, Syndicate* is simply a task gathering a suite of tools that fto anyone easy rotation up their ain concern DAO.

Social DAOs

Social DAOs mean to bring similar minded radical unneurotic successful online communities, coordinated astir a token. The starring illustration is Friends With Benefits and its $FWB token. To join, members indispensable taxable an exertion and get 75 FWB tokens. Entry comes with entree to a assemblage afloat of salient crypto builders, artists, and creatives arsenic good arsenic exclusive events.

By organizing astir a token, members person the inducement to make a invaluable community — share insights, big meetups and propulsion large parties etc. For example, arsenic much radical understood the benefits of joining the FWB community, the token appreciated successful lockstep, sending the $FWB terms from $10 to $75 and truthful rank outgo from astir $750 to around $6,000.

Other societal DAOs usage NFTs arsenic the mechanics for unlocking entree to a broader community. Owning a Bored Ape NFT for example, unlocks entree to the Bored Ape Yacht Club discord, events, NFT airdrops, and merchandise. In this case, the perceived worth of the assemblage drives worth to the postulation of NFTs.

This class of DAOs are each inactive successful their infancy and it volition instrumentality clip to larn which models enactment and which don’t, but the accelerated emergence of these communities suggest that they correspond a almighty caller almighty signifier of societal organization.

Service DAOs

Service DAOs look similar online endowment agencies that bring strangers unneurotic from each implicit the satellite to physique products and services. Perspective clients tin contented bounties for circumstantial tasks and erstwhile completed, wage the DAO treasury a information of the fees earlier rewarding idiosyncratic contributors. Contributors besides typically person governance tokens that convey ownership successful the DAO.

Most of the aboriginal work DAOs, similar DxDAO and Raid Guild, are focused connected bringing endowment unneurotic to physique retired the crypto ecosystem. Their clients dwell of different crypto projects and protocols that request everything from bundle improvement to graphic plan and marketing.

Service DAOs tin reinvent however radical work, allowing a planetary endowment excavation to enactment connected their ain clip and person ownership stakes successful the networks they attraction about. While aboriginal work DAOs are crypto focused, 1 tin envision a aboriginal wherever Uber is replaced by UberDAO that pairs drivers with riders, portion paying drivers an ownership involvement successful the web (though it volition beryllium portion earlier DAOs integrated beyond the purely digital realm).

Media DAOs

Media DAOs purpose to reinvent however some contented producers and consumers prosecute with media. Rather than trust connected advertizing based gross models, these DAOs usage token incentives to reward producers and consumers for their clip with an ownership involvement successful a given outlet.

The thought of decentralized media dates backmost to 2013 with the “Let’s Talk Bitcoin” podcast, but BanklessDAO is simply a starring illustration successful 2021. Bankless is an Ethereum-focused media outlet that produces a fashionable podcast and newsletter. Recently, the Bankless squad airdropped the BANK token to its audience. With BANK acquired, readers tin instrumentality an progressive relation successful the media outlet and gain further BANK by producing content, research, graphic design, nonfiction translations, selling services arsenic good arsenic ballot connected cardinal decisions to nonstop the DAO.

At a clip erstwhile galore hold that the existent ad-based media exemplary is broken, media DAOs contiguous a compelling alternate for realigning the interests betwixt readers and producers.

Grants/Philanthropy DAOs

Grant and doctrine DAOs, akin to concern DAOs, excavation superior and deploy it to assorted endeavors. The lone quality is that allocations are made without the anticipation of a fiscal return.

Gitcoin is simply a pioneer of this model, supporting grants for captious unfastened root infrastructure that whitethorn different person occupation getting funded. Similarly, ample protocols similar Uniswap, Compound, and Aave person circumstantial assistance DAOs that fto the assemblage ballot connected however their treasuries tin beryllium deployed to wage builders and developers to further the protocol.

Philanthropy DAOs are besides starting to look to re-imagine however charitable donations tin beryllium made. Dream DAO for example, issued NFTs to rise funds earlier letting NFT holders ballot connected however those funds should beryllium allocated towards the DAO’s ngo (funding civic leaders successful Gen Z).

The hurdles for DAOs

As this progressively divers scenery shows, DAOs tin go the organizational primitive of Web3, reinventing however we govern, invest, work, create, and donate. Expect to spot the categories, number, and prime of DAOs germinate dramatically successful the future.

That said, they person a agelong mode to go. Consider that DAOs are fundamentally tasked with reverse engineering hundreds of years of lessons learned from ideology and firm governance! The standard of the situation is palpable, and contiguous we admit 4 main deficiencies:

Lack of legal/regulatory clarity
Lack of businesslike coordination mechanisms
Lack of infrastructure
Smart contract, fragmentation, & sustainability risks

Lack of Legal/Regulatory Clarity

Corporations person ever been rooted successful a circumstantial place, with their close to beryllium bestowed archetypal by monarchs, and yet by cities and states. Those aforesaid municipalities person ever acceptable the rules that corporations successful their jurisdiction indispensable abide by. Given that DAOs don’t beryllium successful immoderate 1 spot and don’t run similar corporations, they don’t acceptable cleanly into existing regulatory frameworks.

Where the rules astir forming a caller corp portion protecting members from definite liabilities are good defined, DAOs person to grapple with each sorts of thorny regulatory and ineligible issues. How are DAO tokens and treasury activities treated from a taxation perspective? How should income paid to a DAO subordinate beryllium reported?

In the US, DAOs are presently faced with a faustian bargain of forming an LLC successful a circumstantial jurisdiction oregon being treated arsenic a wide partnership. The erstwhile undermines a DAOs quality to beryllium governed by rules encoded successful astute contracts successful favour of modular LLC articles of incorporation (and being restricted by the constraints of existing LLC law). The second perchance exposes members to liabilities done the partnership, which would different beryllium protected by the “limited liability company (LLC)”.

All of this uncertainty makes it hard for DAOs to interact with non-crypto/Web3 entities, which is simply a large detriment. Wyoming has pushed guardant authorities that volition let DAOs to run connected the aforesaid ineligible footing arsenic accepted LLCs portion allowing them to beryllium governed by their ain astute contracts but has been met with SEC resistance. Meanwhile, a16z, and OpenLaw person projected wide ineligible frameworks for governing DAOs, but DAOs volition person to proceed to run successful a grey country for the foreseeable future.

All of this uncertainty underscores the conception that successful the adjacent term, DAOs maturation volition apt beryllium concentrated purely successful the integer realm — the ineligible complexity gets amplified erstwhile DAOs effort to crossover to the carnal realm (e.g UberDAO).

Lack of businesslike coordination mechanisms

There’s a crushed corporations and governments don’t person each worker oregon national measurement successful connected each decision — it’s a highly inefficient mode of getting things done and not everyone is qualified to do so.

— @AndreCronjeTech

Corporate hierarchies beryllium due to the fact that you often request qualified radical making the hard decisions. Many DAOs contiguous beryllium nether somewhat crude governance structures wherever 1 token equates to 1 vote. In larger DAOs with thousands of token holders, this tin pb to chaotic determination making processes wherever voting powerfulness is much a relation of buying powerfulness than expertise. Similarly, unappointed but high-profile members tin summation oversized power implicit decision making.

Most hold that for DAOs to beryllium genuinely effective, they’ll person to research advancements successful governance structures, similar shifting to a delegated authorization model, wherever token holders tin ballot successful qualified leaders to marque cardinal decisions successful a transparent mode (something Orca Protocol* is exploring). In the adjacent term, it’s apt that DAO governance volition stay messy and chaotic arsenic they experimentation with antithetic models earlier yet figuring retired what works (much similar the agelong experimental way from monarchies to democracy).

Lack of developed infrastructure

Just arsenic corporations bask wide ineligible frameworks and businesslike determination making processes, they besides payment from highly developed infrastructure connected which to operate. DAOs connected the different hand, are tasked with gathering astir of that aforesaid infrastructure from scratch.

DAO tools for governance, payroll, reporting, treasury management, communication, and each different assets astatine the disposal of modern time corporations are inactive nascent. Thankfully, the DAO tooling scenery runs deep, and determination are hundreds of teams moving connected tackling these deficiencies crossed a scope of approaches.

— @balajis

There’s excessively galore large teams to sanction but connected the governance tooling front, we’re excited astir Messari’s* caller aggregator for monitoring and participating successful governance each from 1 interface.

Smart contract, fragmentation, & sustainability risk

It’s hard to sermon DAOs without referencing “The DAO:” The archetypal ever DAO connected Ethereum, designed astir task investing successful 2015, that had 40% of its treasury hacked and drained of $60 million. As the caller $130 cardinal exploit of BadgerDAO showcased, DAO treasuries stay susceptible to astute contract risk.

Similarly, the largest crypto networks person a past of fragmentation caused by part from wrong the community. The Bitcoin/Bitcoin Cash divided was caused by a method quality implicit blocksize. The Ethereum/Ethereum Classic divided was caused by disagreements implicit however to respond to the supra mentioned hack of “The DAO”. It’s tenable to deliberation that we’ll spot the largest DAOs look akin headwinds.

On the different broadside of that coin, however sustainable are DAOs travel different imaginable crypto winter? Will radical proceed to beryllium excited astir DAOs erstwhile token prices are continually falling, treasuries constrict, and some information and rank dwindles?

Re-wiring the satellite with DAOs

While obstacles abound, DAOs correspond a paradigm displacement successful economical organization. If Web3 is to go an net collectively owned by its users, DAOs volition beryllium the organizational primitive successful which that ownership is metered out.

2021 has seen a renaissance successful caller DAO experiments and models. Meanwhile, the scenery of projects and companies gathering retired the tooling needed for DAOs to scope their existent imaginable is among the richest successful the industry. (Coinbase Ventures is actively investing successful the DAO landscape, with a fig of deals successful the pipeline — reach retired if you’re a task pushing the DAO scenery forward!)

Should these trends continue, we whitethorn 1 time spot the biggest organizations, task firms, media outlets, and institutions built not connected ineligible contracts, but connected unfastened crypto networks. As crypto UX improves, DAOs whitethorn precise good usurp the LLC arsenic the preferred mode of enactment successful an progressively digitized world.

PS — Look for much DAO focused products and services coming from Coinbase successful the near future.

Further DAO listening from the Around The Block Podcast:

What the heck is simply a DAO? with Coinbase’s Jesse Pollak
The realities of moving for a DAO, with Kinjal Shah

Previous editions of Around The Block

This website does not disclose worldly nonpublic accusation pertaining to Coinbase oregon Coinbase Venture’s portfolio companies.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed connected this website are those of the authors who whitethorn beryllium associated persons of Coinbase, Inc., oregon its affiliates (“Coinbase”) and who bash not correspond the views, opinions and positions of Coinbase. Information is provided for wide acquisition purposes lone and is not intended to represent concern oregon different proposal connected fiscal products. Coinbase makes nary representations arsenic to the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, suitability, oregon validity of immoderate accusation connected this website and volition not beryllium liable for immoderate errors, omissions, oregon delays successful this accusation oregon immoderate losses, injuries, oregon damages arising from its show oregon use. Unless different noted, each images provided herein are the spot of Coinbase. This website contains links to third-party websites oregon different contented for accusation purposes only. Third-party websites are not nether the power of Coinbase, and Coinbase is not liable for their contents. The inclusion of immoderate nexus does not connote endorsement, support oregon proposal by Coinbase of the tract oregon immoderate relation with its operators.

DAOs: Social networks that tin rewire the world was primitively published successful The Coinbase Blog connected Medium, wherever radical are continuing the speech by highlighting and responding to this story.

View source