First Ethereum Treasury Firm Sells ETH For Buybacks: Death Spiral Incoming?

7 hours ago

Ethereum-focused treasury institution ETHZilla said it has sold astir $40 cardinal worthy of ether to money ongoing stock repurchases, a maneuver aimed astatine closing what it calls a “significant discount to NAV.” In a property connection connected Monday, the institution disclosed that since Friday, October 24, it has bought backmost astir 600,000 communal shares for astir $12 cardinal nether a broader authorization of up to $250 million, and that it intends to proceed buying portion the discount persists.

ETHZilla Dumps ETH For BuyBacks

The institution framed the buybacks arsenic balance-sheet arbitrage alternatively than a strategical retreat from its halfway Ethereum exposure. “We are leveraging the spot of our equilibrium sheet, including reducing our ETH holdings, to execute stock repurchases,” president and CEO McAndrew Rudisill said, adding that ETH income are being utilized arsenic “cash” portion communal shares commercialized beneath nett plus value. He argued the transactions would beryllium instantly accretive to remaining shareholders.

ETHZilla amplified the connection connected X, saying it would “use its beardown equilibrium expanse to enactment shareholders done buybacks, trim shares disposable for abbreviated borrow, [and] thrust up NAV per share” and reiterating that it inactive holds “~$400 cardinal of ETH” connected the equilibrium expanse and carries “no nett debt.” The institution besides cited “recent, concentrated abbreviated selling” arsenic a origin keeping the banal nether pressure.

The market-structure logic is straightforward: erstwhile a digital-asset treasury trades beneath the worth of its coin holdings and cash, buying backmost banal with “coin-cash” can, successful theory, illness the discount and assistance NAV per share. But the optics are contentious wrong crypto due to the fact that the mechanics requires selling the underlying asset—here, ETH—to acquisition equity, perchance weakening the precise treasury backing that investors primitively sought.

Death Spiral Incoming?

Popular crypto trader SalsaTekila (@SalsaTekila) commented on X: “This is highly bearish, particularly if it invites akin behavior. ETH treasuries are not Saylor; they haven’t shown diamond-hand will. If treasury companies commencement dumping the coin to bargain shares, it’s a decease spiral setup.”

Skeptics besides zeroed successful connected backing choices. “I americium mostly funny wherefore the institution chose to merchantability ETH and not usage the $569m successful currency they had connected the equilibrium expanse past month,” different expert Dan Smith wrote, noting ETHZilla had conscionable said it inactive holds astir $400 cardinal of ETH and frankincense didn’t deploy it connected caller ETH accumulation. “Why not conscionable usage cash?” The question cuts to the halfway of treasury signaling: utilizing ETH arsenic a liquidity reservoir to support a discounted equity tin beryllium work arsenic rational superior allocation, oregon arsenic capitulation that undermines the ETH-as-reserve narrative.

Beyond the buyback, a retail-driven storyline has rapidly formed astir the stock. Business Insider reported that Dimitri Semenikhin—who precocious became the look of the Beyond Meat surge—has targeted ETHZilla, saying helium purchased astir 2% of the institution astatine what helium views arsenic a 50% discount to modified NAV. He has argued that the marketplace is misreading ETHZilla’s equilibrium expanse due to the fact that it inactive reflects bequest biotech results alternatively than the existent digital-asset treasury model.

The aforesaid report cites liquid holdings connected the bid of 102,300 ETH and astir $560 cardinal successful cash, translating to astir $62 per stock successful liquid assets, and calls retired a 1-for-10 reverse divided connected October 15 that, successful his view, muddied the optics for retail. Semenikhin flagged November 13 arsenic a imaginable catalyst if results amusement the pivot to ETH generating profits.

The company’s ain messaging emphasizes the discount-to-NAV lens alternatively than a alteration successful strategy. ETHZilla told investors it would support buying portion the banal trades beneath plus worth and highlighted a extremity of shrinking lendable proviso to blunt short-selling pressure.

For Ethereum markets, the contiguous travel effect is limited—$40 cardinal is marginal successful ETH’s regular liquidity—but the second-order hazard flagged by traders is behavioral contagion. If different ETH-heavy treasuries travel the playbook, selling the underlying to bargain their ain stock, the travel could go pro-cyclical: coins are sold to adjacent equity discounts, the selling pressures spot, and wider discounts reappear arsenic equity screens rerate to the weaker mark—repeat.

That is the “death spiral” script skeptics pass astir erstwhile the treasury plus doubles arsenic the company’s awesome of conviction.

At property time, ETH traded astatine $4,156.