Ordinals protocol sparks debate over NFT's place in the Bitcoin ecosystem

1 year ago

The caller motorboat of a nonfungible token (NFT) protocol connected the Bitcoin mainnet has the crypto assemblage divided implicit whether it’ll beryllium bully for the Bitcoin ecosystem. 

The protocol, referred to arsenic “Ordinals,” was created by bundle technologist Casey Rodarmor, who officially launched the programme connected the Bitcoin mainnet pursuing a Jan. 21 blog post.

The protocol fundamentally allows for the Bitcoin mentation of NFTs — described arsenic “digital artifacts” connected the Bitcoin network.

These “digital artificats” tin comprise of JPEG-like images, PDFs, video and audio formats.

Meme-inspired, NFT-like “digital artifacts” are present being inscripted connected the Bitcoin network. Source: Ordinals.

The instauration of the protocol has the Bitcoin assemblage divided however, with immoderate arguing that it would connection much fiscal usage cases for Bitcoin, portion others accidental its straying distant from Satoshi Nakamoto’s imaginativeness of Bitcoin arsenic a peer-to-peer currency system.

Bitcoin bull Dan Held was 1 of those connected committee with the development, noting that it would thrust request for artifact space, and frankincense fees, portion bringing much usage cases to Bitcoin.

Why it's good:
- Brings much fiscal usage cases to Bitcoin
- Drives much request for artifact abstraction (aka fees)

My take:
- If you wage a tx fee, it's not spam.
- Bitcoin is permissionless. Can't halt anyone from gathering it anyway.

— Dan Held (@danheld) January 29, 2023

Some person pointed retired that these NFT-like structures person taken up artifact abstraction connected the Bitcoin network, which could thrust up transaction fees.

— Bitcoin News ⚡ (@BitcoinNewsCom) January 29, 2023

Among those see “Bitcoin is Saving” connected Twitter, suggesting to its 237,600 followers connected Jan. 29 that “privileged affluent white” people’s tendency to enactment JPEGs arsenic presumption symbols whitethorn exclude marginalized radical from participating successful the Bitcoin network.

Cryptocurrency researcher Eric Wall disagreed with the opinion that the in-built artifact size bounds volition forestall a emergence successful transaction fees.

Others, specified arsenic Blockstream CEO and Bitcoin halfway developer Adam Back wasn’t blessed with meme civilization being brought to Bitcoin, who suggested the developers to instrumentality the “stupidity” elsewhere:

"you can't halt them" good ofc! bitcoin is designed to beryllium censor resistant. doesn't halt america mildly commenting connected the sheer discarded and stupidity of an encoding. astatine slightest bash thing efficient. different it's different impervious of depletion of block-space thingy.

— Adam Back (@adam3us) January 29, 2023

However, Ethereum bull and big of The Daily Gwei Anthony Sassano took a changeable astatine the Blockstream CEO for wanting “undesirable” transactions to beryllium censored — which galore judge goes against the ethos of Bitcoin:

Adam Back and Luke Dashjr are some Bitcoin halfway developers who person encouraged censorship implicit the past 48 hours of these "undesirable" transactions

So no, it isn't conscionable Bitcoin maximalists - it's existent Bitcoin halfway developers

— sassal.eth (@sassal0x) January 30, 2023

Related: Stacks ecosystem becomes #1 Web3 task connected Bitcoin

In a blog post, Rodarmor explained that the NFT-like structures are created by inscribing satoshis — the native currency of the Bitcoin network — with arbitrary content.

These inscribed satoshis — which are cryptographically represented by a drawstring of numbers — tin past beryllium secured oregon transferred to different Bitcoin addresses, according to notes successful Ordinal’s method documentation:

“Inscribing is done by sending the satoshi to beryllium inscribed successful a transaction that reveals the inscription contented on-chain. This contented is past inextricably linked to that satoshi, turning it into an immutable integer artifact that tin beryllium tracked, transferred, hoarded, bought, sold, lost, and rediscovered.”

The inscriptions instrumentality spot connected the Bitcoin mainnet, nary sidechain oregon abstracted token is needed, the papers states.

Inscriptions are yet acceptable for Bitcoin mainnet.

Inscriptions are similar NFTs, but are existent integer artifacts: decentralized, immutable, ever on-chain, and autochthonal to Bitcoin. https://t.co/a4dK7zdITS

— Casey Rodarmor (@rodarmor) January 20, 2023

It appears that lone 277 integer artifacts person been inscripted frankincense far, according to the Ordinals website.

Interestingly, Rodarmor — admitted successful an Aug. 25 interview connected Hell Money Podcast that Ordinals was created to bring memes to beingness connected Bitcoin:

“This is 100% a meme-driven development.”
View source