The Perils of Crypto's Pseudonymous Economy

If crypto’s pseudonymous system is to past this epoch of NFT rug pulls and token Ponzinomics, past I’ve yet to spot a crushed wherefore oregon however it should. We’re surviving done a monolithic integer whack-a-mole game. But these moles person mallets – Groucho Marx masks, too. Why, then, bash we support plunking quarters into their machine?

Take Thursday’s announcement of fraud charges against 2 organizers of the “Frosties” non-fungible token blowup. Federal prosecutors alleged 20-year-olds Ethan Nguyen and Andre Llacuna scammed investors successful their million-dollar metaverse mumbo jumbo, a postulation of cutesy JPEG PFPs (profile pics).

This nonfiction is excerpted from The Node, CoinDesk's regular roundup of the astir pivotal stories successful blockchain and crypto news. You tin subscribe to get the afloat newsletter here.

Infected by FOMO (fear of missing out) and crypto hype culture, thousands of well-meaning if misguided victims didn’t cognize who was selling them a tin integer Spam. Some Frosties buyers eagerly dropped thousands of dollars connected mint day. They didn’t commencement asking whodunit until aft the rug had been pulled. Why fuss vetting creators “Meltfrost” and “heyandre” successful an ecosystem that lionizes the pseudonymous hack?

Therein lies the ... rug. Crypto and DeFi (decentralized finance) and NFTs and Web 3 person grown to adore pseudonymity’s romanticist mystique. This makes cleanable consciousness from a humanities standpoint: Bitcoin’s Satoshi Nakamoto acceptable a trillion-dollar precedent for keeping one’s existent sanction nether wraps. He oregon she oregon they created a fiscal disintermediation level that didn’t cognize oregon attraction who utilized it. Years of open-source collaboration, auditing and innovation – and Satoshi’s aboriginal exit signifier near – mean bitcoiners nary fret implicit the founder’s existent name.

Bitcoin earned our respect implicit a decennary of growth. Its pseudonymous precedent is present being exploited by a caller procreation of scam-happy thieves. Carnival goldfish person longer, happier lives than these ringleaders' phony names.

Convicted felon and QuadrigaCX co-founder Michael Patryn rebranded himself arsenic the systemically important treasurer of crypto task Wonderland, which astatine its tallness held implicit $700 cardinal successful assets. People were good with Sifu the pseudonymous founder. When on-chain sleuths doxxed him, though, they balked, yet voting him retired of the project. Sifu didn’t person to tally disconnected with their wealth to propulsion the rug, successful their minds. His potholed past was indictable enough.

If radical cared who Sifu was aft his unmasking, past there’s nary conceivable crushed wherefore they shouldn’t person demanded that accusation connected opening day. You can’t blasted Sifu, really: He was conscionable pursuing way procedure. We rotation ourselves a communicative of riches that charlatans – particularly those with toxic pasts – inevitably embrace.

Crypto is opening to grapple with its self-imposed fables. Perhaps spooked by billions of dollars successful rug pulls, a increasing fig of pseudonymous founder-led projects are present taking steps to bolster their raison d'être. Some clasp their outward-facing enigma by telling retail investors that the whales (large investors) cognize their existent names. Others wage large bucks for boutique vendors to execute “know-your-customer” (KYC) checks successful speech for a beauteous statement that marks them arsenic known privately.

Take RugDoc.io. In 1 year, the reappraisal website has built assemblage spot by spotting and shaming shady DeFi projects. This work laudably warns users which products are programmed to rug and which look safe. It’s a escaped work disposable connected request.

The website besides sells “RUGDOC KYC.” For $5,000+ it volition execute “extensive real-time individuality verification arsenic good arsenic nonrecreational vetting done our trusted 3rd enactment vendor.” After verifying the founders’ individuality (which it keeps nether wraps) RugDoc awards them a “pristine KYC badge” to flaunt earlier RugDoc’s “100k+ monthly unsocial visitors.”

I’ve been around this manufacture agelong capable to cognize that “trusted 3rd parties'' are anathema to the origins of crypto. We don’t cognize who runs RugDoc. We surely don’t cognize who its “trusted 3rd party” is. When asked successful the project’s Discord, the mod Mr. Onion demurred. “Making them nationalist could unfastened up vulnerabilities,” the mod said.

It is definitionally intolerable to spot a 3rd enactment erstwhile the enactment is unknown. Dozens of projects inactive wage large wealth to tally their gamut, which RugDoc calls a deterrent. RugDoc’s ain website admits astatine slightest 2 pulled the rug.

We’re dumping millions of dollars successful an ecosystem whose solution to a occupation of its ain making is simply a banner advertisement antithetical to crypto’s philosophical core. Pretty words and self-principles are trouncing our ain credulity. Then erstwhile it goes down the porcelain throne we outcry boo hoo and determination connected to the next.

It’s lone by a operation of sheer luck and post-teenage stupidity that the feds caught up with the alleged founders of Frosties. According to court documents, a national researcher subpoenaed messaging app Discord, crypto speech Coinbase, net work providers and banks to rather speedily necktie 2 real-world identities to “heyandre” and “Meltfrost.” Two months from transgression to charges is simply a ineligible blitzkrieg, to beryllium sure.

There was a bully crushed to determination fast, the feds say. They allege Nguyen and Llacuna were days distant from launching different scammy NFT rug pull-to-be.