The Truth Behind Cuba’s Bitcoin Revolution: An on-the-ground report

11 months ago

In Cuba’s capital, Havana, a Bitcoin assemblage has emerged from an economically antagonistic environment.

“Satoshi didn’t make Bitcoin for Cubans, but it truly comes successful useful for us,” Forte, co-founder of the aptly named section Bitcoin enactment Cuba Bitcoin, tells Magazine.

Cubans are turning to Bitcoin due to the fact that their wealth is progressively worthless. Zimbabwe, Venezuela and Lebanon often vie for media sum astir runaway ostentation levels, but the Cuban peso is not acold behind.

The Cuban peso has devalued truthful overmuch implicit the past fewer years that carrying bags of currency is progressively communal among the affluent and the poor.
In practice, adjacent if idiosyncratic bought Bitcoin astatine the apical of the 2021 bull tally astatine $69,000, their wealth is worthy overmuch little successful Cuban pesos. Whereas Bitcoin dropped 80% to its carnivore marketplace low, it has since recovered 100%, and the peso has devalued by 90%.

The realization that idiosyncratic should swap section currency for the Bitcoin top, knowing that it volition clang and they’ll inactive clasp much purchasing power, is 1 of the galore fiscal wake-up calls received portion moving connected Cointelegraph’s caller documentary, The Truth Behind Cuba’s Bitcoin Revolution.

In 2021, I came crossed the nonfiction “Inside Cuba’s Bitcoin Revolution” by Human Rights Foundation main strategy serviceman Alex Gladstein, successful which helium explains however and wherefore Cubans were utilizing Bitcoin’s stateless and low-fee properties to prevention wealth and flight fiscal oppression.
In enactment with the Bitcoin mantra of Don’t trust, Verify, I went to spot with my ain eyes what Gladstein described.

Camera successful manus with my trusty question spouse Paco de la India by my side, I web my mode into the Cuba Bitcoin community, which present counts thousands of enthusiasts and advocates.

La Cultura Cubana

Following 1 of the largest fiscal conferences successful the world, Bitcoin Miami, successful arguably the world’s astir capitalist arena, the United States of America, I hop crossed the Caribbean to Cuba, 1 of the fewer extant socialist states. The opposition hits maine harder than the Cuban tropical heat.

From the infinitesimal I landed astatine Havana Jose Marti International Airport, I noticed immoderate comic quirks: doors unfastened manually (forget automatic sensors), check-in and migration are done connected pen and paper, and the taxis are 1950s Chevrolets.

It’s communal to picture visiting Cuba arsenic a clip warp. It’s not hyperbole; Cuba cannot entree satellite markets, fiscal institutions oregon trade. The United States has subjected Cuba to a commercialized embargo — the longest successful modern past — since the land federation nationalized U.S. lipid refineries successful 1960.

As a result, Cuban industry, economical output and commerce lag acold down the modern world.

The embargo, coupled with much than fractional a period of communism, has resulted successful a highly educated, extraordinarily literate but desperately mediocre and bare population, galore of whom person a heartbreaking tendency to permission the island, oregon successful Spanish, to find a “salida” — an exit.

Why enactment successful a state wherever a taxi operator earns much than an atomic technologist — and the emaciated technologist struggles to provender their family?

Adopting Bitcoin

In specified an environment, it’s a wonderment wherefore Cubas don’t flock to Bitcoin arsenic wealth that exists extracurricular of authorities control. However, galore Cubans are learning astir and dilatory turning to Bitcoin.

Catrya, 1 of the main characters successful Cointelegraph’s caller documentary and 1 of the founders of Cuba Bitcoin, explains that determination could beryllium astir 5,000 Bitcoiners successful Cuba, and if you see crypto enthusiasts generally, the fig is higher still.

Cubans bash not person casual on-ramps into crypto. Firstly, those with net connections cannot motion up for Binance, Coinbase oregon Gemini owed to their nationality. For Cuban Americans connected the island, Cuba’s authorities restricts entree to American websites. Cubans bargain Bitcoin peer-to-peer done Telegram oregon WhatsApp groups and astatine in-person meetups.

What amazes maine is the tiny amounts of wealth Cubans enactment speech to prevention wealth oregon “stack sats.” Saving 1,000 satoshis (less than $1 a week) is meaningful to a Cuban connected $40 monthly. The Cuban peso whitethorn not beryllium present successful 10 years, but Bitcoin surely volition be.
The peer-to-peer process is straightforward, but it’s not beginner-friendly, and these hurdles tin hamper adoption — though they bash person a metallic lining, arsenic Catrya explains:

“Since we’re denied [access to exchanges] by default for being Cuban, we tin ne'er bash KYC [Know Your Customer], truthful that’s a bully happening for us, astatine slightest successful presumption of privacy.”

Buying Bitcoin peer-to-peer and storing Bitcoin by taking ownership of the backstage keys is safer. Customers who trusted custodians specified arsenic FTX, BlockFi, Celsius and Vauld with their crypto were wiped out. Cubans don’t person that option, and portion it takes longer, it’s much secure.

Erich Garcia Cruz, the laminitis of QvaPay and BitRemesas — a currency remitter utilizing Bitcoin that boasts tens of thousands of Cuban users — says that the tiny but increasing fig of Bitcoin customers somewhat represents Cuba’s fledgling net culture.

Connectivity and state of information

Cubans could get online successful earnest from 2013. So, portion the remainder of the satellite was enjoying the iPhone 5C and 4G, a fewer fortunate Cubans fortunate to entree a machine could get online that year, albeit with an atrocious net connection.

Now, Cubans tin entree 3G and sometimes 4G connectivity connected their phones. The tech-savvy and younger Cubans usage VPNs to circumnavigate online restrictions.

Generally, the lag successful net infrastructure combined with the outgo and trouble of buying a smartphone connected a frighteningly debased wage means Cuba is mode down successful IT.

In 2021, the World Bank reported that three-quarters of Cuba has entree to the internet. But portion the contented is improving, net censorship is rife, and Cubans are repeatedly told to spot the authorities done state-sponsored TV, newspapers and media.

Independent media publications are classified arsenic “enemy propaganda,” which is thing I was made alert of a fewer times during my investigation. I won’t stock those stories here, but it’s harmless to accidental reciting specified stories would’ve landed maine successful occupation had I stayed successful Cuba.

Two exiled Cuban journalists person since advised maine to debar returning to the land for immoderate time, particularly if the Cointelegraph documentary gets a batch of attention.

A comic caveat to the state-run media is that immoderate Cubans were orange-pilled by Bitcoin proponent Max Keiser. His appearances connected the Russia Today quality transmission were approved for broadcast successful Cuba. Some of Catrya’s peers watched the amusement wherever Keiser bashes fiat currencies and promotes Bitcoin.

And yet, Bitcoin is magic net money; it lives connected the web. If Cubans aren’t online — oregon watching Russia Today — however tin they cognize astir it?

Orange pill Cuba

Bitalion, 1 of the Cuba Bitcoin founders, works successful telecommunications for the government. He explains that arsenic a privileged nationalist assemblage worker, helium benefits from amended net transportation speeds and little online censorship levels.

Bitalion stumbled crossed the Bitcoin achromatic insubstantial successful 2014 and became infatuated with the thought of an independent, borderless currency. He rhetorically poses the question: For those fortunate Cubans who are capable to question abroad, what tin they bring to the caller country? The peso successful their pocket, oregon Bitcoin successful a mobile wallet?

As with the different Bitcoin advocates connected the island, Bitalion volunteers his clip to amended radical and enactment Bitcoin adoption. He’s besides 1 of the fistful of Cubans moving a Bitcoin node. At Cuba’s first-ever Bitcoin-only meetup, helium demonstrates to dozens of Cubans however to wage for goods and services straight to his Lightning Network node.

Cruz, Forte and countless concern owners explicate that Bitcoin is an casual “orange pill” to swallow, peculiarly for the digitally susceptible Cubans. You simply explicate to them that cipher controls it; it’s stateless money.

At look value, Bitcoin is simply a utile instrumentality for a state that has been financially and economically handicapped for generations. But for Forte, Catrya and Bitalion, the ideology of Bitcoin resonates strongly.

Forte jokes, “Satoshi didn’t make Bitcoin for Cubans, but it truly comes successful useful for us.”

In the anticipation of encouraging much Cubans to research Bitcoin, the trio and the Cuba Bitcoin assemblage big monthly acquisition meetups successful which they explicate the principles of Bitcoin and delve into its philosophy.

They precocious introduced the fashionable Mi Primer Bitcoin (My First Bitcoin) programme successful the country, which is already picking up velocity successful El Salvador and volition soon beryllium instructed successful schools nationwide.

Por qué aceptas Bitcoin? Why bash you judge Bitcoin?

QvaPay’s Cruz explains that Bitcoin is the fiscal instrumentality that allows the tiny but increasing fig of Cuban concern owners to entree overseas products.

Recent U.S. statesmanlike administrations had fluctuating policies connected the Cuban embargo, relaxing and tightening antithetic aspects based connected governmental expediency.

Cruz orange-pills suppliers successful an effort to unfastened up the Cuban system to planetary markets wherever possible:

“You are accepting Bitcoin due to the fact that you’re dealing with a backstage [independent] coin. The authorities doesn’t person entree to the transactions you and you person the state to bash immoderate you want.”

The word “freedom,” oregon “libertad,” popped up often arsenic I mingled and met with Cuban Bitcoiners, crypto enthusiasts and entrepreneurs. The information that citizens tin clasp wealth successful a wallet, extracurricular of authorities overreach, appealed to galore Cubans whom the authorities has consistently fto down.

The quality to store wealthiness connected a mobile telephone successful a Bitcoin Lightning wallet alternatively of successful pesos astatine a slope is besides an ratio gain. It means nary much queues astatine banks to currency successful wealth that could devalue by a fewer pesos implicit a slope vacation weekend.

Cruz and 3 different concern owners besides stock that accepting Bitcoin benefits holidaymakers. Adan, a nightclub, barroom and edifice owner, explains that tourists bring a batch of currency to Cuba for abrogation — and that’s risky.

Having Bitcoin connected a mobile telephone successful a wallet is simply a safer mode to question than flashing wads of dollar bills that extremity up connected the achromatic marketplace successful Cuba, inadvertently supporting the illicit and sometimes unsafe achromatic marketplace enactment of exchanging notes successful public.

Adan accepts Bitcoin due to the fact that of the planetary branding the Bitcoin logo brings. It opens up his bars’ doors to different imaginable market. Similar to El Salvador, where Bitcoin tourism has go a trend, bars and restaurants successful Cuba could besides pull holidaymakers to walk satoshis alternatively of pesos astatine the till.

Finally, determination are myriad ways successful which adopting Bitcoin tin pb to affirmative and unexpected outcomes. Mister Navi’s barroom and restaurant, tally by Mr. Navi and his lad Julian, precocious began accepting Bitcoin. Following a speech with Forte, Catrya and Bitalion, the Cuba Bitcoin radical present hosts acquisition Bitcoin meetups astatine the venue.

I tipped 1 of the work unit successful Bitcoin astatine Mr. Navi’s the archetypal time we visited. Five days later, I saw her again erstwhile we went retired for meal with Mr. Navi and Julian. She seems antithetic — I inquire her if she is OK. She confesses that she was mugged a fewer days ago, and the attacker stole her purse, currency and phone.

To her surprise, erstwhile she downloaded the Bitcoin Lightning app wherever I’d tipped her, the funds magically reappeared connected her caller phone. On seeing her wide-eyed reaction, I tipped her again.

It’s wide that, for Cubans, Bitcoin could correspond a captious instrumentality for securing their fiscal aboriginal successful the look of runaway ostentation and authorities interference, oregon arsenic a mode of opening up to embargoed markets and the planetary fiscal world.

Disclaimer: The views, opinions and perspectives expressed successful this nonfiction are those of the writer and are not needfully those of Cointelegraph.

Joseph Hall

Joseph is simply a probe and interrogation writer with a keen involvement successful the monetary argumentation implications of Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies.

View source