The War On Dissent

Online censorship is becoming progressively normalized arsenic increasing restrictions, deplatforming and its different manifestations person go truthful pervasive that galore person simply travel to judge it.

This nonfiction primitively appeared successful Bitcoin Magazine's "Censorship Resistant Issue." To get a copy, visit our store.

Online censorship is becoming progressively normalized arsenic increasing restrictions, deplatforming and its different manifestations person go truthful pervasive that galore person simply travel to judge it. This “new normal” for escaped code is arsenic insidious arsenic it has been gradual, arsenic we are progressively being trained to judge unconstitutional limitations connected what we tin explicit connected the websites that predominate online socialization. Like truthful overmuch of our lives, societal enactment has moved online astatine a accelerated gait successful the past decade, meaning that restrictions imposed upon online code person a disproportionate effect connected code successful general.

The statement that is often deployed to disregard concerns regarding online censorship is the assertion that the ascendant societal media companies are private, not public, entities. However, successful reality, the Big Tech firms that predominate our online lives, peculiarly Google and Facebook, were either created with immoderate engagement of the U.S. nationalist information authorities oregon person go large U.S. authorities and/or subject contractors implicit the past 2 decades.(i,ii,iii,iv,v) When it comes to censoring and deplatforming individuals for claims that tally antagonistic to U.S. authorities narratives, it should beryllium wide that Google-owned YouTube, and different tech platforms owned by contractors to the U.S. subject and quality communities, person a large struggle of involvement successful their stifling of speech.

The enactment betwixt “private” Silicon Valley and the nationalist assemblage has go progressively blurred and it is present a substance of grounds that these companies person illegally passed accusation onto quality services, similar the National Security Agency (NSA), for blatantly unconstitutional surveillance programs aimed astatine American civilians.(vi) All indications constituent to the military-industrial analyzable having expanded into the military-technology-industrial complex.

These days, 1 request lone look astatine important authorities commissions — specified arsenic the National Security Commission connected Artificial Intelligence (NSCAI), headed by erstwhile Google/Alphabet CEO Eric Schmidt — to spot however this de facto public-private concern betwixt Silicon Valley and the nationalist information authorities functions, and its outsized relation successful mounting important tech-related policies for some the backstage and nationalist sectors. For example, that commission, mostly comprised of representatives of the military, quality assemblage and the scions of Big Tech, has helped acceptable argumentation connected “countering disinformation” online. More specifically, it has recommended weaponizing Artificial Intelligence (AI) for the explicit intent of identifying online accounts to deplatform and code to censor, framing this proposal arsenic indispensable to U.S. nationalist information arsenic it relates to “information warfare.”(vii,viii)

There are already respective companies competing to marketplace an AI-powered censorship motor to the nationalist information authorities arsenic good arsenic the backstage sector. One of these companies is Primer AI, a “machine intelligence” institution that “builds bundle machines that work and constitute successful English, Russian, and Chinese to automatically unearth trends and patterns crossed ample volumes of data.” The institution publically states that their enactment “supports the ngo of the quality assemblage and broader DOD by automating speechmaking and probe tasks to heighten the velocity and prime of decision-making.” Their existent roster of clients includes the U.S. military, U.S. intelligence, large American companies similar Walmart and backstage “philanthropic” organizations similar the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.(ix)

Primer’s founder, Sean Gourley, who antecedently created AI programs for the subject to way insurgents successful post-invasion Iraq, asserted successful an April 2020 blog station that “computational warfare and disinformation campaigns will, successful 2020, go a much superior menace than carnal war, and we volition person to rethink the weapons we deploy to combat them.”(x) In that aforesaid post, Gourley argued for the instauration of a “Manhattan Project for truth” that would make a publically disposable Wikipedia-style database built disconnected of “knowledge bases [that] already beryllium wrong galore countries’ quality agencies for nationalist information purposes.” Gourley wrote that “this effort would beryllium yet astir gathering and enhancing our corporate quality and establishing a baseline for what’s existent oregon not.” He concludes his blog station by stating that “in 2020, we volition statesman to weaponize truth.”

Since that year, Primer has been nether declaration with the U.S. subject to “develop the first-ever instrumentality learning level to automatically place and measure suspected disinformation.”(xi) That the word “suspected disinformation” was utilized is nary accident, arsenic galore instances of online censorship impact simply assertions, arsenic opposed to confirmations, that censored code is portion of a federation state-connected oregon “bad actor”-connected organized disinformation campaign. While those campaigns bash exist, morganatic and constitutionally protected code that deviates from the “official” oregon government-sanctioned communicative are often censored nether these metrics, often with small to nary quality to meaningfully entreaty the censor’s decision. In different cases, posts “suspected” of being disinformation oregon that are flagged arsenic specified (sometimes erroneously) by societal media algorithms, are removed oregon hidden from nationalist presumption without the poster’s knowledge.

In addition, “suspected disinformation” tin beryllium utilized to warrant the censorship of code that is inconvenient for peculiar governments, corporations and groups, arsenic determination is nary request to person grounds oregon contiguous a coherent lawsuit that said contented is disinformation — 1 indispensable lone formed suspicion upon it successful bid to person it censored. Further complicating this contented is the information that immoderate claims initially labeled “disinformation” aboriginal go accepted information oregon recognized arsenic morganatic speech. This has happened connected much than 1 juncture during the COVID-19 crisis, wherever contented creators had their accounts deleted oregon their contented censored conscionable for broaching issues similar the lab-leak proposal arsenic good arsenic questions implicit disguise and vaccine efficacy, among galore different issues.(xii, xiii) A twelvemonth oregon 2 later, overmuch of this expected “disinformation” was subsequently admitted to see morganatic avenues of journalistic enquiry and the initial, broad censorship connected these topics was done astatine the behest of nationalist and backstage actors alike owed to their inconvenience to what had erstwhile been the prevailing narrative.(xiv, xv)

Primer is lone 1 of respective companies seeking to make a satellite wherever “truth” is defined by the U.S. nationalist information state, with that rigid explanation past being enforced by Big Tech companies with nary country for debate. Brian Raymond, a erstwhile authoritative for the CIA and the National Security Council who present serves arsenic Primer’s vice president, openly wrote astir this successful November 2020 for Foreign Policy.

In that article, helium stated:

“Companies similar Facebook, Twitter, and Google are progressively moving with U.S. defence agencies to amended aboriginal bundle engineers, cybersecurity experts, and scientists. Eventually, erstwhile public-private spot is afloat restored, the U.S. authorities and Silicon Valley tin forge a agreed beforehand successful bid to efficaciously instrumentality connected fake news.” (xvi)

Particularly troubling is the information that Raymond’s main illustration of “fake news” astatine the clip was the New York Post’s reporting connected the Hunter Biden laptop emails, which — good implicit a twelvemonth aft the information — has present been confirmed arsenic authentic.(xvii) Having the government, and much specifically the nationalist information state, which has conducted a litany of confirmed disinformation and propaganda campaigns implicit the years, specify information and world is hardly accordant with its professed extremity of protecting “democracy.”(xviii) Instead, it protects the interests of the nationalist information authorities itself, whose ain interests are tightly interwoven with those of the country’s progressively entrenched (and enriched) oligarchy.

Not lone bash we person the nationalist information authorities successful a de facto public-private concern with Big Tech to censor online accusation — Now, with the caller motorboat of the Biden administration’s warfare connected home terror, we person the aforesaid nationalist information authorities framing “suspected disinformation” and “conspiracy theories” arsenic nationalist information threats. The argumentation documents that outline this caller warfare enactment that a large “pillar” of the government’s full strategy is to destruct online worldly that they assertion promotes “domestic terrorist” ideologies, including those that “connect and intersect with conspiracy theories and different forms of disinformation and misinformation.” The proliferation of “dangerous” accusation “on Internet-based communications platforms specified arsenic societal media, file-upload sites and end-to-end encrypted platforms”, it argues, “[…] tin harvester and amplify threats to nationalist safety.” The “front lines” of this warfare are “overwhelmingly private-sector online platforms.”

The occupation with this framing is that the Biden administration’s explanation of “domestic terrorist” utilized successful these aforesaid documents is incredibly broad. For example, it labels absorption to firm globalization, capitalism and authorities overreach arsenic “terrorist” ideologies. This means that online contented discussing “anti-government” and/or “anti-authority” ideas, which whitethorn simply beryllium criticisms of authorities argumentation oregon the nationalist powerfulness structure, could soon beryllium treated successful the aforesaid mode arsenic online Al Qaeda oregon ISIS propaganda. In addition, quality agencies successful some the U.K. and U.S. person moved to dainty captious reporting of COVID-19 vaccines and mandates arsenic “extremist” propaganda, contempt the information that a important percent of Americans person chosen not to get the vaccine and/or reason vaccine mandates.

In what appears to beryllium the evident fulfilment of Primer AI executives’ pleas, the Biden medication besides underscores the request to “increase integer literacy” among the American public, portion censoring “harmful content” disseminated by “domestic terrorists” arsenic good arsenic by “hostile overseas powers seeking to undermine American democracy.” The second is simply a wide notation to the assertion that captious reporting of U.S. authorities policy, peculiarly its subject and quality activities abroad, was the merchandise of “Russian disinformation,” a now-discredited assertion that was utilized to heavy censor autarkic media. Regarding “increasing integer literacy,” the argumentation documents marque it wide that this refers to a caller “digital literacy” acquisition program that is presently being developed by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), the U.S.’ domestically-focused quality agency, for a home audience. This “digital literacy” inaugural would person antecedently violated U.S. law, until the Obama medication worked with Congress to repeal the Smith-Mundt Act, which lifted the World War II-era prohibition connected the U.S. authorities directing propaganda astatine home audiences.

The Biden administration’s warfare connected home panic argumentation besides makes it wide that the censorship, arsenic described above, is portion of a “broader priority” of the administration, which it defines arsenic follows:

“[…] enhancing religion successful authorities and addressing the utmost polarization, fueled by a situation of disinformation and misinformation often channeled done societal media platforms, which tin teardrop Americans isolated and pb immoderate to violence.”

In different words, fostering spot successful authorities portion simultaneously censoring “polarizing” voices who distrust oregon knock the authorities is simply a cardinal argumentation extremity down the Biden administration’s caller domestic-terror strategy. In addition, this connection implies that Americans not agreeing with each different is problematic and frames that disagreement arsenic a operator of violence, arsenic opposed to a mean occurrence successful a expected ideology that has law protections for state of speech. From this framing, it is implied that specified unit tin lone beryllium stopped if each Americans spot the authorities and hold with its narratives and “truths.” Framing deviations from these narratives arsenic nationalist information threats, arsenic is done successful this argumentation document, invites the labeling of non-conforming code arsenic “violence” oregon arsenic “inciting violence” done the fomentation of disagreement. As a result, those who station non-conforming code online whitethorn soon find themselves being labeled arsenic “terrorists” by the state.

If we are to judge the “new normal” of online censorship, these efforts to prohibit statement and morganatic criticisms of authorities argumentation successful the sanction of “national security” volition proceed unimpeded. In abbreviated order, the First Amendment volition beryllium redefined truthful that it lone protects government-sanctioned speech, not the freedom of speech, arsenic was intended. While specified measures are often framed arsenic indispensable to “protect” democracy, the elimination and imminent criminalization of morganatic code is the existent menace to democracy, 1 that should profoundly disturb each Americans. If the nationalist information authorities controls and enforces the lone permissible narratives and the lone permitted mentation of the “truth,” they volition past besides power quality perception, and — arsenic a effect — quality behavior.

Such power has agelong been a extremity of immoderate wrong the U.S.’ subject and quality communities, but it is anathema to the values and desires of the immense bulk of Americans. If determination is nary meaningful pushback against the expanding fusion of the nationalist information authorities and Big Tech, Americans are guaranteed to suffer overmuch much than conscionable the state of speech, arsenic controlling code is conscionable the archetypal measurement towards controlling each behavior. Americans would bash good to retrieve the informing of Benjamin Franklin arsenic the U.S. authorities moves to criminalize escaped code nether the guise of protecting nationalist security; “Those who would springiness up indispensable liberty, to acquisition a small impermanent safety, merit neither liberty nor safety.”

Endnotes:

i Webb, Whitney. “The Military Origins of Facebook.” Unlimited Hangout, 12 Apr. 2021, unlimitedhangout.com/2021/04/investigative-reports/the-military-origins-of-facebook/.

ii Ahmed, Nafeez. “How the CIA Made Google.” Medium, INSURGE intelligence, 22 Jan. 2015, medium.com/insurge-intelligence/how-the-cia-made-google-e836451a959e.

iii Feiner, Lauren. “Google’s Cloud Division Lands Deal with the Department of Defense.” CNBC, 20 May 2020, www.cnbc.com/2020/05/20/googles-cloud-division-lands-deal-with-the-department-of-defense.html.

iv Novet, Jordan. “Microsoft Wins U.S. Army Contract for Augmented Reality Headsets, Worth up to $21.9 Billion implicit 10 Years.” CNBC, 31 Mar. 2021, www.cnbc.com/2021/03/31/microsoft-wins-contract-to-make-modified-hololens-for-us-army.html.

v Shane, Scott, and Daisuke Wakabayashi. ““The Business of War”: Google Employees Protest Work for the Pentagon.” The New York Times, 4 Apr. 2018, www.nytimes.com/2018/04/04/technology/google-letter-ceo-pentagon-project.html.

vi “Commissioners.” NSCAI, www.nscai.gov/commissioners/.

vii Interim Report and Third Quarter Recommendations. 2020.

viii PrimerAI Homepage.” PrimerAI, primer.ai/.

ix “To Fight Disinformation, We Need to Weaponise the Truth.” PrimerAI, 20 Apr. 2020, primer.ai/blog/to-fight-disinformation-we-need-to-weaponise-the-truth/.

x AI, Primer. “SOCOM and US Air Force Enlist Primer to Combat Disinformation.” www.prnewswire.com, 1 Oct. 2020, www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/socom-and-us-air-force-enlist-primer-to-combat-disinformation-301143716.html/.

xi Forget Counterterrorism, the United States Needs a Counter-Disinformation Strategy.” PrimerAI, 16 Nov. 2020, primer.ai/blog/forget-counterterrorism-the-united-states-needs-a-counter-disinformation/.

xii Golding, Bruce. “Washington Post Joins New York Times successful Finally Admitting Emails from Hunter Biden Laptop Are Real.” New York Post, 30 Mar. 2022, nypost.com/2022/03/30/washington-post-admits-hunter-biden-laptop-is-real/.

xiii Greenwald, Glenn. “The CIA’s Murderous Practices, Disinformation Campaigns, and Interference successful Other Countries Still Shape the World Order and U.S. Politics.” The Intercept, 21 May 2020, theintercept.com/2020/05/21/the-cias-murderous-practices-disinformation-campaigns-and-interference-in-other-countries-still-shapes-the-world-order-and-u-s-politics/.

xiv Ferreira, Roberto Garcia. “The Cia and Jacobo Arbenz: History of a Disinformation Campaign .” Journal of Third World Studies, vol. 25, no. 2, 2008, pp. 59–81, www.jstor.org/stable/45194479, 10.2307/45194479.f.

xv National Strategy for Countering Domestic Terrorism, June 2021. https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/National-Strategy-for-Countering-Domestic-Terrorism.pdf.

xvi Webb, Whitney. “US - UK Intel Agencies Declare Cyber War connected Independent Media.” Unlimitedhangout.com, 11 Nov. 2020, unlimitedhangout.com/2020/11/reports/us-uk-intel-agencies-declare-cyber-war-on-independent-media/.

xvii Webb, Whitney. “Lifting of US Propaganda Ban Gives New Meaning to Old Song.” MintPress News, 12 Feb. 2018, www.mintpressnews.com/planting-stories-in-the-press-lifting-of-us-propaganda-ban-gives-new-meaning-to-old-song/237493/.

xviii National Strategy for Countering Domestic Terrorism, June 2021. https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/National-Strategy-for-Countering-Domestic-Terrorism.pdf/.