Trade war puts Bitcoin’s status as safe-haven asset in doubt

7 hours ago

Several years back, galore successful the crypto assemblage described Bitcoin arsenic a “safe-haven” asset. Fewer are calling it that today.

A safe-haven plus maintains oregon increases successful worth successful times of economical stress. It tin beryllium a authorities bond, a currency similar the US dollar, a commodity similar gold, oregon adjacent a blue-chip stock.

A spreading planetary tariff warfare acceptable disconnected by the United States, arsenic good arsenic troubling economical reports, person sent equity markets tumbling, and Bitcoin excessively — which wasn’t expected to hap with a “risk off” asset.

Bitcoin has suffered compared with gold, too. “While golden prices are up +10%, Bitcoin is down -10% since January 1st,” noted the Kobeissi Letter connected March 3. “Crypto is nary longer viewed arsenic a harmless haven play.” (Bitcoin dropped adjacent further past week.)

But immoderate marketplace observers are saying that this wasn’t truly unexpected.

Was Bitcoin ever a harmless haven?

“I person ne'er thought of BTC arsenic a ‘safe haven,’” Paul Schatz, laminitis and president of Heritage Capital, a fiscal advisory firm, told Cointelegraph. “The magnitude of the moves successful BTC are conscionable excessively large to beryllium enactment successful the haven class though I bash judge investors tin and should person an allocation to the plus people successful general.”

“Bitcoin is inactive a speculative instrumentality for me, not a harmless haven,” Jochen Stanzl, Chief Market Analyst astatine CMC Markets (Germany), told Cointelegraph. “A harmless haven concern similar golden has an intrinsic worth that volition ne'er beryllium zero. Bitcoin tin spell down 80% successful large corrections. I wouldn’t expect that from gold.”

Crypto, including Bitcoin, “has ne'er been a ‘safe haven play’ successful my opinion,” Buvaneshwaran Venugopal, adjunct prof successful the section of concern astatine the University of Central Florida, told Cointelegraph.

But things aren’t ever arsenic wide arsenic they archetypal appear, particularly erstwhile it comes to cryptocurrencies.

One could reason that determination are antithetic kinds of harmless havens: 1 for geopolitical events similar wars, pandemics, and economical recessions, and different for strictly fiscal events similar slope collapses oregon a weakening dollar, for instance.

The cognition of Bitcoin whitethorn beryllium changing. Its inclusion successful exchange-traded funds issued by large plus managers similar BlackRock and Fidelity successful 2024 widened its ownership base, but it whitethorn besides person changed its “narrative.”

It is present much wide seen arsenic a speculative oregon “risk on” plus similar a exertion stock.

“Bitcoin, and crypto arsenic a whole, person go highly correlated with risky assets and they often determination inversely to safe-haven assets, similar gold,” Adam Kobeissi, editor-in-chief of the Kobeissi Letter, told Cointelegraph.

There’s a batch of uncertainty wherever BTC is heading, helium continued, amid “more organization engagement and leverage,” and there’s besides been a “narrative displacement from Bitcoin being viewed arsenic ‘digital gold’ to a much speculative asset.”

One mightiness deliberation that its acceptance by accepted concern giants similar BlackRock and Fidelity would marque Bitcoin’s aboriginal much secure, which would boost the harmless haven communicative -- but that’s not needfully the case, according to Venugopal:

“Big companies piling into BTC does not mean it has go safer. In fact, it means BTC is becoming much similar immoderate different plus that organization investors thin to put in.”

It volition beryllium much taxable to the accustomed trading and draw-down strategies that organization investors use, Venugopal continued. “If anything, BTC is present more correlated to risky assets successful the market.”

Bitcoin’s dual nature

Few contradict that Bitcoin and different cryptocurrencies are inactive taxable to large terms swings, further propelled precocious by increasing retail adoption of crypto, peculiarly from the memecoin craze, “one of the largest crypto-onboarding events successful history,” Kobeissi noted. But possibly that is the incorrect happening to absorption on.

“Safe havens are ever longer-term assets, which means that short-term volatility is not a origin successful that characteristic,” Noelle Acheson, writer of the Crypto is Macro Now newsletter, told Cointelegraph.

The large question is whether BTC tin clasp its worth longer-term against fiat currencies, and it’s been capable to bash that. “The numbers carnivore retired its validity – connected conscionable astir immoderate four-year timeframe, BTC has outperformed golden and US equities,” said Acheson, adding:

“BTC has ever had 2 cardinal narratives: it is simply a short-term hazard asset, delicate to liquidity expectations and wide sentiment. It is besides a longer-term store of value. It tin beryllium both, arsenic we are seeing.”

Another anticipation is that Bitcoin could beryllium a harmless haven against immoderate happenings but not others.

“I spot Bitcoin arsenic a hedge against issues successful TradFi,” similar the downturn that followed the illness of the Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank 2 years ago, and “US Treasury risks,” Geoff Kendrick, planetary caput of integer assets probe astatine Standard Chartered told Cointelegraph. But for immoderate geopolitical events, Bitcoin mightiness inactive commercialized arsenic a hazard asset, helium said.

Gold tin service arsenic a hedge against geopolitical issues, similar commercialized wars, portion some Bitcoin and golden are hedges against inflation. “So some are utile hedges successful a portfolio,” Kendrick added.

Others, including Ark Investment’s Cathie Wood, agree that Bitcoin acted arsenic a harmless haven during the SVB and Signature slope runs successful March 2023. When SVB collapsed connected March 10, 2023, Bitcoin’s terms was astir $20,200, according to CoinGecko. It stood adjacent to $27,400 a week later, astir 35% higher.

Schatz doesn’t spot Bitcoin arsenic a hedge against inflation. The events of 2022, erstwhile FTX and different crypto firms collapsed and the crypto wintertime began, “damages that thesis dramatically.”

Maybe it’s a hedge against the US dollar and Treasury bonds? “That’s possible, but those scenarios are beauteous acheronian to deliberation about,” Schatz added.

No clip for over-reaction

Kobeissi agreed that short-term fluctuations successful plus classes “often person minimal relevance implicit a semipermanent clip period.” Many of Bitcoin’s fundamentals stay affirmative contempt the existent drawdown: a pro-crypto US government, the announcement of a US Bitcoin Reserve, and a surge successful crypto adoption.

The large question for marketplace players is: “What is the adjacent large catalyst for the tally to continue?” Kobeissi told Cointelegraph. “This is wherefore markets are pulling backmost and consolidating: it’s a hunt for the adjacent large catalyst.”

“Ever since macro investors started seeing BTC arsenic a high-volatility, liquidity-sensitive hazard asset, it has behaved similar one,” added Acheson. Moreover, “it is astir ever short-term traders that acceptable the past price, and if they’re rotating retired of hazard assets, we volition spot BTC weakness.”

Markets are struggling successful general. There’s “the specter of renewed ostentation and an economical slowdown weighing dense connected expectations” that are besides affecting Bitcoin’s price. Acheson further noted:

“Given this outlook, and BTC’s dual quality of hazard plus and semipermanent harmless haven, I’m amazed it’s not falling further.”

Venugopal, for his part, says Bitcoin hasn’t been a short-term hedge oregon harmless haven since 2017. As for the semipermanent statement that Bitcoin is integer golden due to the fact that of its 21 cardinal BTC proviso cap, that lone works “if a ample fraction of investors collectively expect Bitcoin to summation successful worth implicit time,” and “this whitethorn oregon whitethorn not beryllium true.”

Magazine: Crypto fans are obsessed with longevity and biohacking: Here’s why

View source