Wall Street’s Latest ‘Market Manipulation’ Scandal Should Be a Wake-Up Call for Crypto

This week saw the melodramatic apprehension and transgression charging of Bill Hwang, the erstwhile manager of the backstage hedge money Archegos Capital Management. You whitethorn retrieve that Archegos blew up past March. Banks that had lent it wealth for huge, leveraged trades coiled up losing $10 cardinal dollars.

There’s a fascinating treatment to beryllium had astir whether what Hwang did was full-blown fraud, but I won’t fuss trying to outdo Matt Levine connected that front. Instead, I privation to absorption connected the fiscal mechanics of what Archegos was up to, and wherefore it’s highly important for cryptocurrency holders oregon traders to understand.

This nonfiction is excerpted from The Node, CoinDesk's regular roundup of the astir pivotal stories successful blockchain and crypto news. You tin subscribe to get the full newsletter here.

The seed of it is simple: Archegos borrowed a batch of wealth and utilized it to bargain precise ample amounts of astir 10 antithetic stocks. That buying itself helped propulsion the stocks up, giving Archegos insubstantial profits that it could usage to get much wealth – which it past utilized to bargain the aforesaid fewer stocks, pushing them up further. The leverage play produced unthinkable results for a time: Hwang reportedly launched Archegos with conscionable $200 cardinal successful 2013, but by its peak, the fund’s insubstantial worth topped $30 billion, a 1,400% instrumentality successful 8 years.

But it was a maneuver with a constricted support life. Archegos implicit clip accumulated utterly absurd positions successful respective large stocks. According to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Archegos came to ain arsenic overmuch arsenic 45% of the outstanding shares successful Tencent and implicit 50% of ViacomCBS (now Paramount Global) shares. One of the pillars of the fraud lawsuit against Hwang is that helium lied to banks astir these levels erstwhile borrowing money. And the mode things played retired shows wherefore banks don’t often oregon willingly lend into this benignant of concentration.

ViacomCBS was the pin that popped the Archegos bubble. The banal ran from astir $35 successful January of 2021 to astir $95 by March. I’m speculating, but it seems precise plausible that Archegos’ ain assertive buying (read: alleged marketplace manipulation) contributed to the insane runup that motivated the merchantability of caller stock. Either way, astir tripling your wealth is good!

Except erstwhile it’s not. The runup motivated ViacomCBS execs to contented caller shares, which successful crook deflated the stock, which dropped 30% successful 3 days. With its precocious levels of attraction and leverage, that 30% driblet successful a azygous banal coiled up being capable to gain Archegos the world’s worst borderline call. With the insubstantial worth of its holdings dropping against its outstanding indebtedness obligations, Archegos was forced to liquidate – yet nuking the full fund.

But – and this is the really, truly important portion – there inactive wasn’t capable to wage backmost its lenders.

Archegos shows what mightiness hap to immoderate fig of crypto assets that are leveraged oregon backed successful definite ways. The cardinal word present is exit liquidity, and 1 takeaway is the information of backing oregon holdings concentrated successful a fewer assets which tin illness abruptly successful a liquidity crisis. In galore cryptocurrency ecosystems, token holders are successful overmuch the aforesaid presumption arsenic the banks that lent to Hwang: astatine hazard of being trapped successful a token arsenic it burns down astir them.

I wrote past week astir the imaginable for an unwind of the terraUSD (UST) stablecoin, which by the astir generous mentation is presently “backed” by a azygous asset, LUNA. The Luna squad is moving to diversify that backing to debar the benignant of concentrated hazard that nuked Hwang, but their existent extremity would get them each the mode up to 3 antithetic assets by adding BTC and AVAX. Hwang coiled up being excessively fragile portion holding person to 10 large positions.

Another suggestive parallel present is with the mechanics of crypto valuations successful general, peculiarly erstwhile it comes to laminitis rewards, pre-mines oregon different ample pools of tokens held successful comparatively static blocks. As galore person pointed out, the “market cap” metric touted by galore tokens is rendered beauteous meaningless by these ample allocations, which are fundamentally not connected the market, and often ne'er person been. The aforesaid mightiness beryllium argued for the lockups successful definite lending and staking protocols.

These large blocks of untraded tokens inflate the full marketplace worth of coins successful a mode rather akin to however Archegos inflated its portfolio. Though pre-mine and staking effects are subtler, some make a misleading cognition of the scarcity of oregon request for an asset. And both, though for antithetic reasons, tin pb to retail investors getting their faces ripped off: If you saw ViacomCBS spiking successful March of past twelvemonth and bought in, you coiled up being Bill Hwang’s exit liquidity arsenic helium torched it from $97 down to $48 successful conscionable 7 days. You could astir apt person a precise therapeutic chat with a SafeMoon holder.

And let’s not hide the mediocre banks (heaven forbid!). Credit Suisse, for instance, shouldered the bulk of Archegos lender losses, eating $4.7 billion. That was successful crook capable to sound astir 18% disconnected Credit Suisse’s banal terms successful a substance of days aft Archegos fell. The slope was already troubled earlier this incident, and its banal has not recovered successful the twelvemonth since.

Bill Hwang whitethorn beryllium a criminal, oregon helium whitethorn person simply been playing the Wall Street crippled according to a acceptable of unwritten but accepted rules – aft all, successful this time and age, cheating and lying are practically qualifications for moving successful precocious finance. Crypto has the chiseled vantage of transparency – Hwang couldn’t person caused arsenic overmuch harm if helium hadn’t concealed his levels of attraction and leverage. In astir cases, akin behaviour by a furniture 1 oregon different protocol would beryllium overmuch much visible. The question is whether traders and investors are paying capable attraction to what’s close determination connected the blockchain to debar a replay of Archegos, successful crypto form.

The Festival for the Decentralized World

Thursday - Sunday, June 9-12, 2022

Austin, Texas